Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

猫笔刀|我也接到催交税的电话了

CDT 档案卡
标题:我也接到催交税的电话了
作者:moomoocat
发表日期:2025.7.18
来源:微信公众号“猫笔刀”
主题归类:税收
CDS收藏:话语馆
版权说明:该作品版权归原作者所有。中国数字时代仅对原作进行存档,以对抗中国的网络审查。详细版权说明

想了想这件事还是和诸位分享一下,就心平气和的客观描述。

其实第一个电话大概是20多天前打来的,对方说是北京xx区税务局的工作人员,查到我海外有投资账户,来和我对接一下纳税事宜。我当时第一反应是确认对方身份,她说电话可以查是税务局的,如果我不信可以去网上查询有没有这回事。我说我需要时间确认,她说好,就把电话挂了。

等到第二次再给我打就是两三天前的事,她问我确认过了吗,我说ok,然后就是进入正题。

她说要交的税主要是两部分,一部分是港股上市公司每年分红的部分,要交20%的税,这个我觉得合理,以前用离岸券商免交一部分红利税,算是个规则漏洞,现在政府发现了,找上门了,该交就交。

另一部分是年度炒股盈利的部分,要交20%的税。我听完以后就皱起了眉头,我说我今年炒股赚10万的话要交2万的税?她说是的,我说炒a股从来没听说过盈利要交税,她说现在炒国外股票盈利要交税了。

我思考了一下,询问了一个很重要的问题,那假如我100万存进去,前面几年亏到只剩50万,今年行情好,赚回到90万,比起最初存进去的本金我还亏10万,这种情况下我今年40万的盈利要交税吗?她说是的,要交8万的税。

“所以我在总计亏10万的情况下,还要交这8万的税?”“是的,要交税。”

我感慨这显得很不近人情。她说这次是征税特别行动,正常情况应该是每一笔股票盈利了都要交20%,现在能给你们按照年度统一结算已经是政策优惠了。

我当时听完脑瓜子就嗡嗡的,每一笔股票盈利都要交20%,真的有这样的资本利得税吗….?

我尝试继续沟通,我说我假设的情况其实就是港股的真实情况,过去四五年行情一直很差,就是去年下半年才好起来涨了一些,很多股民都是亏了好几年今年才刚解套盈利,这一下交税很可能又给我们干亏损了,投资港股也是支援中国金融市场,能否把历史上的盈亏统一结算,然后交盈利部分的20%?

她说不行,企业纳税都是年度结算的,不能说你去年亏了,今年盈利部分就和去年亏损抵扣,今年盈利就交今年的20%。

到这我已经知道没什么可说的,我问她如果我对这个纳税方法有异议,我能通过哪些渠道反馈,她说有一个12366的电话可以打,或者我先把税交了,然后申请行政复议。

我说谢谢,我需要时间去了解一下更多情况,就把电话挂了。

其实我之前听到某些地区有很多股民接到电话,都尝试过和税务人员沟通,申请多年累计结算豁免。就是我一共投进去多少本金,扣完以后盈利的部分交20%,有按照这个条件谈成的,我需要去确认一下。

如果按照这位税务人员说的计算方法,炒港股就太难了,现在港股含中量越来越高,以后很可能也像a股一样围绕着某个点位来回来回震荡10年20年,万一真的这样,很可能就是亏几年赚几年,亏的都是自己的,赚的要交20%,这样的港股就炒不下去了。

无论如何后续我会尝试再去沟通申请多年合并结算,如果最终谈不下来的话,我把税都交完后要可能会考虑清退港股,因为按照这个规则炒股觉得性价比很低,甚至不如a股。

我对这方面的法规不懂,急需学习补课,如果有经验的专家网友能给我建议的话欢迎留言,记得关键词加上“建议”,这样我可以搜索看到。

以下评论由CDT辑自微信公众号:

家居出海:我不管,总之你要交税,不满意的地方,你可以投诉或者复议,(那是另外部门的事)

猫笔刀:对方说建议我先交税,就有资格申请行政复议,忍不住笑了,我也想笑,但没笑出来。[囧]

Enlyace:逼回大A或者币市啊

猫笔刀:呵呵,也考虑过在香港买一套房,现在香港买房所有的税费都没了,我也挺喜欢那个城市的。

朱凡:是怎么知道你持有港股的呢?

猫笔刀:对方说获得一份名单,知道哪些人开了境外的账户,没说这个名单哪来的,但想来政府找那些离岸券商要,他们没有说不的选项。

不言:大概率是骗子

猫笔刀:不用自欺欺人,她说我不信可以打开个税app去核实有没有这个事,还有人建议我拉黑她的电话,哈哈哈,如果不接电话就能避税的话,这和掩耳盗铃有什么区别😂

呼风唤雨:好像港股通不用交20%的税

猫笔刀:这个在电话里也聊到了,说港股通的免税政策只到2027年,2027年以后一视同仁,不过我没有去查对方说的这个政策。

M:还有个问题,如果当年的港股是亏损的,亏损部分可以抵扣国内个人所得税的税基吗?

猫笔刀:你想的美,中国没有炒股亏损抵扣个税的规则。

MDreams:海外账户不是离岸账户吗,现在也能查到?

猫笔刀:有部分地区的公司会把crs数据共享,你可以去问一下deepseek关于crs数据共享的话题,我这里就不展开了。但也有一部分地区的公司不和中国政府共享数据,比如美国。

立娜:他们通过什么渠道查到你的盈利情况呢?境外证券户应该没法打通啊

猫笔刀:据说他们现在只是知道哪些人在境外开户投资了,但具体的交易细节他们不知道,需要你自律申报,这件事我目前也还在学习,对实际情况还了解的不全面。

夜航船:建议:这个有管辖权么?你不是没有北京户口么?

猫笔刀:我的社保什么的都在北京交,税也是交在北京,所以就由这边的税务局来管辖这没毛病。有些奇怪的是我社保交在海淀,但打电话给我的是另一个区,这让我很意外,她说是市区往下分配名单分到她这里的。

Bedouins and Druze clash in Syria despite 'immediate ceasefire'

Getty Images Syrian military and security forces in Suweida. Photo: 15 July 2025Getty Images
Syrian military and security forces in Suweida. Photo: 15 July 2025

The Syrian presidency says it will deploy a new force to halt the deadly sectarian clashes between Bedouin and Druze fighters in the south of the country.

Syrian interim President Ahmed al-Sharaa's office urged "all parties to exercise restraint", amid reports of renewed fighting near the city of Suweida on Friday.

Almost 600 people are reported to have been killed since the violence erupted on Sunday. Government troops deployed to the area were accused by residents of killing Druze civilians and carrying out extrajudicial executions.

Israel later struck targets in Syria to force the troops to withdraw from Suweida province. On Friday, the US ambassador to Turkey said that Israel and Syria had agreed a ceasefire.

In a post on X, ambassador Tom Barrack said that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Sharaa "have agreed to a ceasefire" embraced by Syria's neighbours Turkey and Jordan.

"We call upon Druze, Bedouins, and Sunnis to put down their weapons and together with other minorities build a new and united Syrian identity in peace and prosperity with its neighbours," the envoy said.

Israel and Syria have not publicly commented on the reported ceasefire agreement.

Shortly before Sharaa's office announced its planned military deployment to the south, an Israeli official said Israel had agreed to allow the limited entry of Syrian Internal Security Forces personnel into Suweida for 48 hours to protect Druze civilians "in light of the ongoing instability".

Suweida's predominantly Druze community follows a secretive, unique faith derived from Shia Islam, and distrusts the current jihadist-led government in Damascus.

The BBC correspondent in the Syrian capital says that sectarian hatred of the Druze is now spreading across the country.

The Druze are a minority in Syria, as well as in neighbouring Lebanon and Israel.

Earlier this week, the UN human rights chief, Volker Türk, said his office had received credible reports indicating widespread violations and abuses, including summary executions and arbitrary killings in Suweida.

Among the alleged perpetrators were members of the security forces and individuals affiliated with the interim government, as well as local Druze and Bedouin armed elements, Türk said in a statement.

"This bloodshed and the violence must stop," he warned, adding that "those responsible must be held to account".

The BBC has contacted the Syrian government and security forces about allegations of summary killings and other violations.

In a televised address early on Thursday, Sharaa vowed to hold the perpetrators accountable and promised to make protecting the Druze a "priority".

"We are eager to hold accountable those who transgressed and abused our Druze people because they are under the protection and responsibility of the state," he said.

He went on to blame "outlaw groups", saying their leaders "rejected dialogue for many months".

Home secretary pledges new power to stop violent attackers

Getty Images The police cordon in Southport following the attack. Getty Images
Three young girls were murdered and 10 others seriously injured by Axel Rudakubana in Southport in July 2024

The home secretary says a powerful new crime to target suspects who are found to be preparing mass killings will ensure their plotting is taken as seriously as terrorism.

Yvette Cooper said the criminal justice system had to be given new tools to respond to violence-fixated individuals who are not motivated by a particular ideology, in the wake of the Southport attack last year.

Terror suspects who take steps towards an attack can be jailed for life, even if their plans are not fully formed.

Cooper told the BBC that the government will "close the gap" between such offenders and lone, violence-obsessed individuals by giving police the power to apprehend them long before they can act.

Axel Rudakubana is serving a life sentence for murdering three girls when he attacked a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in Southport almost a year ago.

Eight others girls were seriously injured, along with two adults who tried to stop the killer.

Had police found he had been researching a target prior to the attack, they could not have arrested and charged him with a serious offence because he had no ideological motive linked to the definition of terrorism.

Speaking to BBC Radio 4's State of Terror series, which charts the response to violent extremism over the 20 years since the 7/7 bombings, Cooper said the police will get the power to prevent such individuals who do not have a clear ideology, in the same way they can with terror suspects.

Reuters Yvette Cooper in ParliamentReuters
Yvette Cooper said the government would "tighten" the law so planning a mass attack be "taken as seriously as terrorism"

"There is a gap in the law around the planning of mass attacks that can be just as serious [as terrorism] in their implications for communities, their impact, the devastation that they can cause and the seriousness of the crime," she said.

"We will tighten legislation so that that is taken as seriously as terrorism."

Cooper said the plan - which was briefly announced in March but not fleshed out until now - was for the new law to be similar to the exceptionally serious crime of preparing for acts of terrorism.

This legislation, brought in after the 2005 London bombings, is a vital counter-extremism tool that has jailed dozens of suspects.

It allows the police to arrest a terror suspect for the steps they take to prepare for an attack - such as researching a target.

But it stipulates that there must also be evidence the preparation is linked to an ideological cause, such as support of a group banned under terrorism laws.

Youtube Nicholas Prosper seen wearing a yellow bucket hat.Youtube
Nicholas Prosper was jailed for murdering his family - but was also researching a school attack

The planned non-terror offence would apply to a far wider range of scenarios, including the activity of individuals like Nicholas Prosper. He had been planning a mass school shooting before he was apprehended for murdering his family.

Cooper said: "We've seen cases of growing numbers of teenagers potentially radicalising themselves online and seeing all kinds of extremist material online in their bedrooms.

"They're seeing a really distorted and warped online world.

"We have to make sure that that the systems can respond while not taking our eye off the ball of the more long-standing ideological threats."

State of Terror continues on Monday on BBC Radio 4 and BBC Sounds.

'Great British Energy solar panels' were made in China

PA Media UK households are installing more heat pumps and solar panels than ever before, the body that accredits low-carbon products has said. Issue date: Monday August 14, 2023.PA Media

The first schools in England to install what the government described as "Great British Energy solar panels" were made in China, the BBC has learned.

The first 11 schools involved in the GB Energy scheme bought solar panels from Aiko and Longi, two Chinese firms.

The government said the scheme was "the first major project for Great British Energy - a company owned by the British people, for the British people".

Labour MP Sarah Champion said GB Energy should be buying solar panels from companies in the UK rather than China, where there have been allegations of forced labour in supply chains.

"I'm really excited about the principle of GB Energy," she told BBC News.

"But it's taxpayers' money and we should not be supporting slave labour with that money. And wherever possible, we should be supporting good working practices and buy British if we can."

She added: "That means that yes, unfortunately, in the short term, solar panels are probably going to be slightly more expensive.

"There are solar panels made around the world in Taiwan, Canada, even in the UK."

Longi and Aiko both told the BBC they forbid forced labour in their production and supply chains.

China is the world's leading producer of solar panels and the suppliers in the Xinjiang region have been linked to the alleged exploitation of Uyghur Muslims.

Earlier this year, the law was changed to ban GB Energy from investing in renewables if there is evidence of modern slavery in their production.

China has dominated the market and, according to the International Energy Agency, the country's global share in all the manufacturing stages of solar panels exceeds 80%.

Champion, who is chair of the International Development Select Committee, said "abuse in renewable supply chains is insidious and hard to root out".

But she urged ministers to exclude known human-rights offenders from winning public contracts.

A GB Energy spokesperson said all of the solar contracts issued under the schools initiative complied with the UK's modern slavery rules.

The Xinjiang challenge

Up to 50% of the world's supply of polysilicon - a key component in solar panels - is estimated to come from the Xinjiang region.

Mark Candlish is the director of GB-Sol, which calls itself the only manufacturer of conventional solar panels in the UK.

He said polysilicon was "a key social issue facing our industry, with the risk of forced labour in the main mining areas".

He added: "The global solar market is so dominated by China that it is difficult to avoid buying Chinese if you want the low cost energy and low carbon benefits of solar PV."

Many businesses and governments - including the UK's - buy Chinese solar panels because they are cheaper than those made elsewhere.

Two thirds (68%) of the solar panels imported by the UK came from China in 2024, according to HMRC trade data. That's an increase on the figure in 2023, when Chinese products accounted for 61% of UK solar imports.

A report by Sheffield Hallam University in 2023 linked various solar companies to suppliers in the Xinjiang region.

One of the report's authors, Alan Crawford, said the general lack of transparency in the entire solar supply chain was greater now than it was in 2023, when his Over-Exposed report was published.

"Companies that were willing to comment are now silent," he said.

'Ethical supply chains'

GB Energy is a state-owned company that was set up by the Labour government to invest in renewables, such as solar power.

In its first big investment, GB Energy is spending about £200m on rooftop solar for 200 schools and NHS hospitals across the country.

The first tranche of this funding has been spent on the Chinese solar panels for the 11 schools.

The Department for Education told the BBC which companies had made the solar panels in response to a freedom of information request.

A GB Energy spokesperson said the company would "lead the way in ethical supply chains" and insisted there was "no place for forced labour or unethical practices in the UK's energy transition".

The spokesperson added: "That is why we are introducing a statutory duty on Great British Energy to prevent modern slavery in its supply chains, and reviewing supplier transparency and disclosure standards to ensure confidence in all public-facing renewable programmes.

"All contracts issued under this schools and hospitals solar initiative complied with UK procurement rules, including extensive requirements under the Modern Slavery Act.

"GBE will seek to uphold these requirements in its contracting arrangements and are actively engaging with international partners to raise the bar globally on solar supply chain accountability."

China has been accused of committing crimes against humanity against the Uyghur population and other mostly-Muslim ethnic groups in the north-western region of Xinjiang.

In state-sponsored programmes, detainees are forced to produce goods including polysilicon, a core ingredient in solar panels, according to the US Department of Labor.

The Chinese government has denied all allegations of human rights abuses in Xinjiang.

Longi and Aiko are both members of the Solar Stewardship Initiative, which is a scheme designed to develop confidence in the supply chain and the responsible sourcing of solar panels.

An Aiko spokesperson said the company was "committed to upholding the highest standards of ethical business conduct and responsible sourcing".

"We take any concerns related to human rights and labour practices seriously and expect our suppliers to do the same," the spokesperson said.

"As part of our ongoing efforts, we engage with suppliers to promote transparency and continuous improvement in line with international guidelines. We are also closely monitoring global supply chain developments and remain committed to working with stakeholders to support a fair and sustainable solar industry."

Longi said it regretted the findings of the Sheffield Hallam University report and "categorically affirms that forced labour has no place within our supply chain".

A company spokesperson said the conclusions in the Over-Exposed report "may not fully reflect the comprehensive measures Longi has implemented to ensure full compliance with international labour standards".

"Independent third-party audits play a critical role in verifying compliance and identifying potential risks," the spokesperson said.

"While the complexity of global supply chains presents challenges, Longi remains steadfast in its efforts to eliminate any risks associated with forced labour."

Usyk destroys Dubois to reclaim undisputed crown

Usyk blows Dubois away to reclaim undisputed crown

Oleksandr Usyk lands a left hand on Daniel DuboisImage source, Queensberry
Image caption,

Oleksandr Usyk (right) has won all four fights as a professional on UK soil

Oleksandr Usyk further cemented his place as one of boxing's greats by stopping Daniel Dubois in round five to become a two-time undisputed heavyweight champion.

The Ukrainian put on a masterclass in front of 90,000 fans at Wembley Stadium to dash Dubois' dreams of being the first Briton to unify the division in the four-belt era.

Usyk, 38, put Dubois down twice in the fifth and the Londoner was unable to return to beat the count the second time round.

He also stopped Dubois in 2023 and extends his perfect record as a professional to 24 victories.

"I'm sorry [Dubois], it's sport. My people wanted this win," Usyk told DAZN.

"Nothing is next. It's enough. Next, I want to rest. My family, my wife, my children, I want to rest now. Two or three months, I want to just rest."

Dubois – who beat Anthony Joshua to defend his IBF title in September – tastes defeat for the third time in 25 contests as a professional, with each of those losses coming inside the distance.

Usyk reclaimed the IBF title, which was stripped from him just weeks after unifying the division in 2023, and added it to his WBA (Super), WBO and WBC belts.

"I have to commend him on the performance, I gave everything I had. Take no credit away from that man, I'll be back," Dubois told DAZN.

"I was just fighting, trying to pick up round by round. It is what it is."

Usyk still top of the heavyweight pile

Daniel Dubois on the canvas with Oleksandr Usyk standing over himImage source, Queensberry
Image caption,

Usyk has now won all 13 of his world title fights across two divisions

The great and good of the boxing world turned out to watch the momentous occasion, with Roy Jones Jr and Frank Bruno among those at ringside.

WBO interim heavyweight champion Joseph Parker was also keeping a close eye on proceedings as he seeks a date with Usyk next.

Usyk, who has called the UK his second home, was welcomed warmly after Dubois had also been cheered to the ring.

It took no time for the fight to spark into life as Dubois doubled up on his jab but it was clear that Usyk wasn't going to be a sitting target. The former undisputed cruiserweight champion was far too slick, ducking under the jab and punishing Dubois regularly.

Southpaw Usyk punctuated each of the opening two rounds with a counter left and had Dubois looking a little unsteady in the second.

Dubois looked out of the ring to his father Stan between rounds for some advice but he still found it difficult to pin down the 2012 Olympic gold medallist.

Usyk unloaded in the fifth and sent Dubois tumbling to the canvas with a crisp left.

Dubois showed incredible spirit to beat the count but the writing was already on the wall.

Another trusty left hook landed clean on Dubois' chin and his corner threw in the towel as the referee reached the count of nine.

Dubois left with another rebuilding job

Oleksandr Usyk holds his four world titlesImage source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Usyk has now beaten Anthony Joshua, Tyson Fury and Daniel Dubois twice

A third career defeat leaves Dubois in a difficult position and requiring another rebuild.

Dubois, 27, has not beaten a champion to claim a world title – he won the interim IBF belt and was subsequently elevated to full world champion before making one defence against Joshua.

Following his last defeat by Usyk, Dubois re-emerged with a newfound confidence but this loss will knock him back several steps.

He will have no shortage of options with the likes of interim WBC champion Agit Kabayel, WBA 'Regular' champion Kubrat Pulev or even the likes of Deontay Wilder to go after.

Usyk, meanwhile, is the A side in boxing's glamour division and has his pick of the bunch.

"Maybe it's Tyson Fury. Maybe we have three choices, Derek Chisora and Anthony Joshua, maybe Joseph Parker," Usyk told DAZN.

Dubois' team raised concerns over Usyk's age during fight week but he looked as good as ever.

As he has done in all previous rematches – against Fury and Joshua – Usyk used the data he had downloaded from the first encounter to his advantage.

Related topics

More boxing from the BBC

How the rise of green tech is feeding another environmental crisis

BBC A treated image of a wide shot of Salar de Atacama, ChileBBC

Raquel Celina Rodriguez watches her step as she walks across the Vega de Tilopozo in Chile's Atacama salt flats.

It's a wetland, known for its groundwater springs, but the plain is now dry and cracked with holes she explains were once pools.

"Before, the Vega was all green," she says. "You couldn't see the animals through the grass. Now everything is dry." She gestures to some grazing llamas.

For generations, her family raised sheep here. As the climate changed, and rain stopped falling, less grass made that much harder.

But it worsened when "they" started taking the water, she explains.

Ben Derico/BBC Raquel Celina Rodriguez speaks to reporter Ione WellsBen Derico/BBC
Raquel's family raised sheep in Chile's Atacama salt flats for generations but now everything is dry, she says

"They" are lithium companies. Beneath the salt flats of the Atacama Desert lie the world's largest reserves of lithium, a soft, silvery-white metal that is an essential component of the batteries that power electric cars, laptops and solar energy storage.

As the world transitions to more renewable energy sources, the demand for it has soared.

In 2021, about 95,000 tonnes of lithium was consumed globally - by 2024 it had more than doubled to 205,000 tonnes, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA).

By 2040 it's predicted to rise to more than 900,000 tonnes.

Most of the increase will be driven by demand for electric car batteries, the IEA says.

Locals say environmental costs to them have risen too.

So, this soaring demand has raised the question: is the world's race to decarbonise unintentionally stoking another environmental problem?

Flora, flamingos and shrinking lagoons

Chile is the second-largest producer of lithium globally after Australia. In 2023, the government launched a National Lithium Strategy to ramp up production through partly nationalising the industry and encouraging private investment.

Its finance minister previously said the increase in production could be by up to 70% by 2030, although the mining ministry says no target has been set.

This year, a major milestone to that is set to be reached.

Ben Derico/BBC A barren landscape scene in ChileBen Derico/BBC
The process extracts vast amounts of water in this already drought-prone region

A planned joint enterprise between SQM and Chile's state mining company Codelco has just secured regulatory approval for a quota to extract at least 2.5 million metric tonnes of lithium metal equivalent per year and boost production until 2060.

Chile's government has framed the plans as part of the global fight against climate change and a source of state income.

Mining companies predominantly extract lithium by pumping brine from beneath Chile's salt flats to evaporation pools on the surface.

The process extracts vast amounts of water in this already drought-prone region.

Ben Derico/BBC A close up shot of Faviola GonzalezBen Derico/BBC
Biologist Faviola González monitors environmental changes in the Los Flamencos National Reserve, which is home to salt flats, marshes and lagoons

Faviola Gonzalez is a biologist from the local indigenous community working in the Los Flamencos National Reserve, in the middle of the Atacama Desert, home to vast salt flats, marshes and lagoons and some 185 species of birds. She has monitored how the local environment is changing.

"The lagoons here are smaller now," she says. "We've seen a decrease in the reproduction of flamingos."

She said lithium mining impacts microorganisms that birds feed on in these waters, so the whole food chain is affected.

She points to a spot where, for the first time in 14 years, flamingo chicks hatched this year. She attributes the "small reproductive success" to a slight reduction in water extraction in 2021, but says, "It's small."

"Before there were many. Now, only a few."

The underground water from the Andes, rich in minerals, is "very old" and replenishes slowly.

"If we are extracting a lot of water and little is entering, there is little to recharge the Salar de Atacama," she explains.

Lucas Aguayo Araos/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images Flamingos fly in Laguna Chaxa in Salar de Atacama, Chile Lucas Aguayo Araos/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images
'The lagoons here are smaller now. We've seen a decrease in the reproduction of flamingos'

Damage to flora has also been found in some areas. On property in the salt flats, mined by the Chilean company SQM, almost one-third of the native "algarrobo" (or carob) trees had started dying as early as 2013 due to the impacts of mining, according to a report published in 2022 by the US-based National Resources Defense Council.

But the issue extends beyond Chile too. In a report for the US-based National Resources Defense Council in 2022, James J. A. Blair, an assistant professor at California State Polytechnic University, wrote that lithium mining is "contributing to conditions of ecological exhaustion", and "may decrease freshwater availability for flora and fauna as well as humans".

He did, however, say that it is difficult to find "definitive" evidence on this topic.

Mitigating the damage

Environmental damage is of course inevitable when it comes to mining. "It's hard to imagine any kind of mining that does not have a negative impact," says Karen Smith Stegen, a political science professor in Germany, who studies the impacts of lithium mining across the world.

The issue is that mining companies can take steps to mitigate that damage. "What [mining companies] should have done from the very beginning was to involve these communities," she says.

For example, before pumping lithium from underground, companies could carry out "social impact assessments" - reviews which take into account the broad impact their work will have on water, wildlife, and communities.

Getty Images Lithium mining process shown in a vast and barren landscapeGetty Images
Extracting lithium involves pumping brine from beneath Chile's salt flats to evaporation pools on the surface

For their part, mining companies now say they are listening. The Chilean firm SQM is one of the main players.

At one of their plants in Antofagasta, Valentín Barrera, Deputy Manager of Sustainability at SQM Lithium, says the firm is working closely with communities to "understand their concerns" and carrying out environmental impact assessments.

He feels strongly that in Chile and globally "we need more lithium for the energy transition."

He adds that the firm is piloting new technologies. If successful, the idea is to roll these out in their Salar de Atacama plants.

These include both extracting lithium directly from brine, without evaporation pools, and technologies to capture evaporated water and re-inject it into the land.

"We are doing several pilots to understand which one works better in order to increase production but reduce at least 50% of the current brine extraction," he said.

Ben Derico/BBC Close up shot of Valentín Barrera wearing a hard hatBen Derico/BBC
Valentín Barrera says Chilean firm SQM understands concerns and is working with communities

He says the pilot in Antofagasta has recovered "more than one million cubic metres" of water. "Starting in 2031, we are going to start this transition."

But the locals I spoke to are sceptical. "We believe the Salar de Atacama is like an experiment," Faviola argues.

She says it's unknown how the salt flats could "resist" this new technology and the reinjection of water and fears they are being used as a "natural laboratory."

Sara Plaza, whose family also raised animals in the same community as Raquel, is anxious about the changes she has seen in her lifetime.

She remembers water levels dropping from as early as 2005 but says "the mining companies never stopped extracting."

Ben Derico/BBC Landscape in the Vega with grass and some animals grazing in the distanceBen Derico/BBC
'The companies give the community a little money, but I'd prefer no money. I'd prefer to live off nature and have water to live'

Sara becomes tearful when she speaks about the future.

"The salt flats produce lithium, but one day it will end. Mining will end. And what are the people here going to do? Without water, without agriculture. What are they going to live on?"

"Maybe I won't see it because of my age, but our children, our grandchildren will."

She believes mining companies have extracted too much water from an ecosystem already struggling from climate change.

"It's very painful," she adds. "The companies give the community a little money, but I'd prefer no money.

"I'd prefer to live off nature and have water to live."

The impact of water shortages

Sergio Cubillos is head of the association for the Peine community, where Sara and Raquel live.

He says Peine has been forced to change "our entire drinking water system, electrical system, water treatment system" because of water shortages.

"There is the issue of climate change, that it doesn't rain anymore, but the main impact has been caused by extractive mining," he says.

He says since it started in the 1980s, companies have extracted millions of cubic metres of water and brine – hundreds of litres per second.

"Decisions are made in Santiago, in the capital, very far from here," he says.

Lucas Aguayo Araos/Anadolu via Getty Images Aerial view of lithium mining pits in Atacama Salt Flat, ChileLucas Aguayo Araos/Anadolu via Getty Images
Chile is the world's second-largest lithium producer, after Australia

He believes that if the President wants to fight climate change, like he said when he ran for office, he needs to involve "the indigenous people who have existed for millennia in these landscapes."

Sergio understands that lithium is very important for transitioning to renewable energy but says his community should not be the "bargaining chip" in these developments.

His community has secured some economic benefits and oversight with companies but is worried about plans to ramp up production.

He says while seeking technologies to reduce the impact on water is welcome that "can't be done sitting at a desk in Santiago, but rather here in the territory."

Ben Derico/BBC Sergio Cubillos speaks to Ione WellsBen Derico/BBC
Sergio Cubillos says his community should not be a "bargaining chip"

Chile's government stresses there has been "ongoing dialogue with indigenous communities" and they have been consulted over the new Codelco-SQM joint venture's contracts to address concerns around water issues, new technologies and contributions to the communities.

It says increasing production capacity will be based on incorporating new technologies to minimise the environmental and social impact and that the high "value" of lithium due to its role in the global energy transition could provide "opportunities" for the country's economic development.

Sergio though worries about their area being a "pilot project" and says if the impact of new technology is negative, "We will put all our strength into stopping the activity that could end with Peine being forgotten."

A small part of a global dilemma

The Salar de Atacama is a case study for a global dilemma. Climate change is causing droughts and weather changes. But one of the world's current solutions is – according to locals – exacerbating this.

There is a common argument from people who support lithium mining: that even if it damages the environment, it brings huge benefits via jobs and cash.

Daniel Jimenez, from lithium consultancy iLiMarkets, in Santiago, takes this argument a step further.

He claims that environmental damage has been exaggerated by communities who want a pay-out.

Lucas Aguayo Araos/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images A view of the Salar de Atacama Lucas Aguayo Araos/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images
What's happening in the Salar de Atacama is a case study for a global dilemma - and debate

"This is about money," he argues. "Companies have poured a lot of money into improving roads, schools – but the claims of communities really go back to the fact they want money."

But Prof Stegen is unconvinced. "Mining companies always like to say, 'There are more jobs, you're going to get more money'," she says.

"Well, that's not particularly what a lot of indigenous communities want. It actually can be disruptive if it changes the structure of their own traditional economy [and] it affects their housing costs.

"The jobs are not the be all and end all for what these communities want."

Ben Derico/BBC Wide panoramic scene at sunset showing two birds in the distanceBen Derico/BBC
'Our sacred birds that are disappearing,' says Faviola

In Chile, those I spoke to didn't talk about wanting more money. Nor are they opposed to measures to tackle climate change. Their main question is why they are paying the price.

"I think for the cities maybe lithium is good," Raquel says. "But it also harms us. We don't live the life we used to live here."

Faviola does not think electrifying alone is the solution to climate change.

"We all must reduce our emissions," she says. "In developed countries like the US and Europe the energy expenditure of people is much greater than here in South America, among us indigenous people."

"Who are the electric cars going to be for? Europeans, Americans, not us. Our carbon footprint is much smaller."

"But it's our water that's being taken. Our sacred birds that are disappearing."

Top image credit: Getty Images

BBC InDepth is the home on the website and app for the best analysis, with fresh perspectives that challenge assumptions and deep reporting on the biggest issues of the day. And we showcase thought-provoking content from across BBC Sounds and iPlayer too. You can send us your feedback on the InDepth section by clicking on the button below.

Should school summer holidays be shorter?

Tara Moore/Getty Images A seagull flies and several stand in front of a family sitting along a wall by a pebble covered beach at Herne Bay in Kent. A young boy is sitting in a green beach chair while a woman is sitting on the wall wearing a light grey top and pink shorts. Next to her is a boy with his mouth wide open who is wearing a trilby-style hat and blue over shirt with white t-shirt underneath. Then there is a man in a similar hat, sunglasses and a blue shirt, a woman in a yellow dress and another boy in t-shirt and shorts with his legs in a triangle along the wall.Tara Moore/Getty Images

Shorter school summer holidays may sound like a child's nightmare – but they could be a relief for parents who are trying to juggle childcare with their jobs.

Some schools now have five-week breaks in the summer, but a two-week October half term. But is there an argument for shorter summers at all schools?

Could a shorter break help with learning? Or do pupils - and teachers - need the time to recharge? Would spreading out school holidays across the year help reduce the cost of family holidays, or would smaller windows create a rush to book time off?

Let's take a look at some of the issues.

Would it help parents and pupils?

Branwen Jeffreys
Education Editor@branwenjeffreys

Six weeks is a long time away from learning, especially for children whose parents are working or who can't afford lots of costly day trips, activities or a long family holiday.

So while all children may forget a little of what they have learnt, families with more money can enrich their understanding by giving them other experiences, and this widens the learning gap.

For many families with children, food is one of the biggest bills. During term time, more than a quarter of children across England are eligible for free school meals, and in some schools, it is closer to half of all pupils.

As food costs have risen, there has been growing awareness of what is called holiday hunger, with some families struggling to feed children without school support.

There are other factors too. While summer allows for playing outside, footy kickarounds and being in the garden, extending winter holidays may mean families need to heat their homes more in the daytime.

England, Wales and Scotland all have six-week summer breaks, though Scotland's tends to be earlier, finishing in mid-August.

In Northern Ireland, schools are closed for all of July and August.

Most of England's schools are now academies who can set their own holidays, and some have already opted for five weeks in summer and two weeks in October. In Surrey, the county council has decided to follow suit for all the schools it supports from autumn 2026.

In Wales, that model was put out to consultation, attracting more than 16,000 responses from parents and teachers. It was divisive. Only a narrow majority were in favour and in June 2024, the plans were put on hold.

Parentkind, the charity for parent-teacher organisations, has released polling suggesting 53% of parents would like a four-week summer holiday, rising to 60% in families with a child with special educational needs.

The same polling also suggests a four-week break is much less popular with teachers, with only 24% in favour of the idea. This may ultimately be a stumbling block. It is hard to recruit teachers because for the rest of the year, they have little to no flexibility in their working patterns, unusual now for many graduate roles. Summer is when teachers recharge and also pack in their planning and lesson preparation ahead of September.

However, earlier this year, the chief inspector of schools at Ofsted, Sir Martyn Oliver, said he thought shorter breaks could be beneficial. He said after the long summer holiday, some children returned "dysregulated" and struggling to adapt to routine.

Cheaper trips but a battle for leave?

Faarea Masud
Business reporter
Getty Images Three girls with school bags walk in a park, with their backs to the camera. One of them is wearing a light blue uniform and carrying a red school bag. Next to her is a girl wearing a red dress and carrying a yellow bag, walking alongside a third girl in a white shirt and green skirt with a pink bag on her shoulder.Getty Images

The price of going away during the six-week school holidays can be eye-watering.

This is because the high demand from parents and those working in education for those dates means travel firms can hike prices up and still sell out.

So spreading some of these weeks out across the year could provide more opportunities to go away and lessen demand at any one time, thus bringing down prices.

However, if the summer holiday was only four weeks long, it could also have the opposite effect of squashing the demand into a smaller time frame and pushing up prices further.

One way to mitigate this would be for different regions to stagger their school summer holidays, suggests Which? Travel editor, Rory Boland.

Holiday prices would come down "only if travel firms can restrain themselves from massively inflating prices", he says.

Any price drops could also come at the expense of those who currently avoid going away during the school summer holidays, as they might find there are fewer bargains to be had.

There could also be an impact on traffic jams, airport queues and overcrowded trains if everyone isn't making a dash for it at the same time.

If there was a shorter summer break, employers would have to navigate a higher number of holiday requests over a smaller period of time.

For instance, three people wanting to take two weeks off each over summer could be staggered over six weeks, but over four weeks might prove more tricky.

If leave isn't possible, bosses should "carefully consider" flexible working to help balance workload with childcare, says David D'Souza, director of profession at the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD).

Are hotter summers a factor?

Different countries have different holiday setups and it often comes down to weather.

Hot countries like India - which has around two months of summer holiday - tend to have longer breaks, while more temperate countries often go shorter.

In South Korea, the winter break is longer than the summer one, though some parents have suggested this should be evened out.

Germany has a rotation system between the 16 states, though the Guardian recently reported there was a dispute due to two southern regions historically claiming what are seen as the prime slots because of their traditional harvests.

The Met Office said this week that extreme weather was the new normal for the UK and with changing weather, do we need to change how we think about the summer break?

According to BBC Weather forecaster Darren Bett, climate change means we are already seeing warmer, wetter winters and hotter, drier summers - a pattern that is expected to continue.

Heatwaves are expected to occur more often (there have already been three this year during exam season), but the hottest weather usually comes between July and August when the air and land has had longer to heat up.

Darren says hay fever could also be an issue for pupils, particularly those sitting exams.

He says a study by the University of Worcester showed oak and grass pollen seasons are starting earlier and birch pollen is becoming more severe.

His conclusion is that the summer holidays should be longer and exams taken in autumn, but we're not sure how that would work.

How do kids feel about it?

BBC Newsround
A composite of three school children. Sam is a boy with short brown hair, he is smiling and wearing a dark hooded top and white shirt. Grace has long dark brown hair and is smiling widely. She's wearing a white shirt and grey dress. Betsy has long blonde hair in a ponytail over one shoulder. She is smiling and waring a daisy necklace  over a dark hooded top
Sam, Grace and Betsy have mixed views on changing the summer break

It's easy for us adults to discuss things like costs and working arrangements. But what do those who are arguably most affected think? We asked pupils at a primary school in Manchester.

Sam, in year six, says he thinks we should have longer holidays "because, in countries like Ireland and Spain, they have 9-11 weeks."

"Lots of people are saying that our generation don't play out," he says, "but I think it's the complete opposite, because if we had longer, we would definitely play out more and we wouldn't be bored because we'd plan more things."

But Betsy, also in year six, says she is concerned about what that might mean for her learning. "I think we should keep the holidays the same because, say, if I was on a holiday for 12 weeks and you go back to school, then it might take a while to get settled into your friend group and remember everything you've learnt for the last year and get used to the whole school vibe."

Grace, in year five, says if holidays were longer she'd get a lot more bored as, "You won't see your friends as much".

"You'll see lots of family but you won't see as much of your friends and you could be asking when are we going back, because I'd be a little bit bored."

Thin, blue banner with title text in white that says “Summer Essential” and a subheading in white saying, “Your family’s guide to the summer.” On the right there are yellow and orange concentric circles forming an abstract image of the sun.

Sign up for Summer Essential, a weekly newsletter to help parents and families during the holidays.

Parked in lay-bys - the drivers determined to avoid airport drop-off fees

BBC Caroline O'Brien sitting in her car looking directly at the camera. She is wearing a blue top. She is visible from the shoulders up and is sitting in the driver's seat with the steering wheel in front of her. There is a road and foliage in the background.BBC
Caroline O'Brien parked in a layby near the main terminal building to avoid paying the drop-off charge

It's a hot and sticky Friday in the middle of the summer holidays and cars are flooding onto Edinburgh Airport's approach road.

There are few places to stop, but in almost every layby a steady stream of drivers await friends and loved ones touching down from their holidays.

They are all parked in a half-mile radius from the entrance to the terminal building in a bid to beat so-called "kiss-and-fly" charges in the official drop-off zone.

Research by the RAC, released this week, found that more than half of the country's busiest airports have raised drop-off fees in the last 12 months.

In Edinburgh, drivers face a £6 tariff for a 10-minute stay at a specific drop-off zone yards from the main terminal building.

Every minute beyond that allowance will cost them an extra £1.

A layby near a roundabout at Edinburgh Airport. There are four cars. The car closest to the camera is red. The cars further away are dark coloured, either black or grey.
A layby near a roundabout at Edinburgh Airport was almost full

Instead, drivers here look to beat the system, waiting in nooks and crannies along Eastfield Road for a message that their passengers have arrived.

They then drive a few hundred metres towards the Moxy or Hilton hotels and pick them up as they leave the airport complex, exiting hastily to avoid risking a fine for parking on double yellow lines.

Close to the Moxy, next to a farm gate by a grass verge, Caroline O'Brien, 52, is waiting in a layby for her husband and children after they returned from a holiday to Paris.

She says she had previously been charged £24 for under 30 minutes in the drop-off zone and decided not to take any chances this time.

"You don't know if the plane is going to be early or late in and I don't want them to be standing around," she says.

"For pick-up and drop-off, I think a couple of pounds [would be fair]. You're only there a few minutes for them to get their cases and then right back in the car and away again."

A general view of the entrance to the pick-up and drop-off zone at Edinburgh Airport. A blue sign advertising the zone is over the top of the road and states their are four lanes. Underneath each lane marker on the sign is a black screen with green writing featuring the word "spaces".
The pickup and drop-off zone at Edinburgh Airport does not inform drivers about fees on their approach

Drivers approaching via Eastfield Road pass three roundabouts on the way into the main terminal, the closest of which leads them on to a one-way system which means they have to pass through the drop-off zone.

There is no signage on the approach to inform them of the charges, however there is when they are already inside the drop-off zone.

Drivers pay once they exit the drop-off area.

A sign displaying the pickup and drop-off charges at Edinburgh Airport. The text is white on a teal blue background. Above it is a white box with black writing which reads: 0-10 mins £6. £1 per minute thereafter.
Edinburgh Airport is among those to have increased their prices in the last year

London Gatwick, Bristol, Leeds Bradford, Southampton and Stansted charged the top rate of £7 in the RAC survey.

Edinburgh is level with London Heathrow, Birmingham, Liverpool John Lennon and Glasgow in charging £6 for the initial drop off.

By contrast, at nine of the 10 busiest airports in the European Union there are no drop-off fees.

Rontom Tschopp, 32, from Switzerland, had just dropped a friend off at the terminal but was unaware there would be a charge for doing so.

Rontom Tschopp smiling right at the camera. He is standing up but only the top half of his body is visible. He has his right thumb up to the camera. He has a short, dark beard and long, dark hair tied back. He is wearing a black T-shirt with a woman on it in black and white. He is standing in front of a black car and a silver car which are blurred in the background.
Rontom Tschopp said there were no drop-off charges at his local airport in Switzerland

He says his local airport, in Basel, did not charge for the same service.

He says: "I was a bit flabbergasted to be honest, because we don't have that in Switzerland.

"I think it creates a form of aversion to do the little things like drop off your friends. If I had known about the fees, we probably wouldn't have had such a heartfelt goodbye, it would have been: 'No, go now, there's extra fees'."

Sheila McPheely sitting in the driver's seat of a blue car. She is smiling at the camera. She has blonde hair and is wearing a white T-shirt with grey writing on it.
Sheila McPheely said the free drop-off zone was useful for some, but not those with mobility issues.

Edinburgh Airport does have other road links with the city centre through bus services, while the tram network also stops just outside.

It also has a free drop-off zone about half a mile (0.8km) from the main terminal building, across the tram line and near a car rental service.

Drivers can park there for 30 minutes free of charge, but it costs £10 up to an hour after that and £18 for between one and three hours.

Up another side street, near a vacant commercial business, Shiela McPheely is waiting to collect her sisters from their holiday in Albufeira in Portugal.

She says the cost of the drop-off zone is "appalling" and is planning to pick her sisters up at the free drop-off point, despite both having mobility issues.

"It's just greedy. You pay enough for your flights and when you get in there, you get a tea or a coffee, so they are getting money from you that way," Sheila, 79, says.

"There is a bit you can park in that is free, but that is all very well if you are young and fit, but one of my sisters has a sore back, the other one is waiting for a hip operation, so it's difficult for them."

Gavin Marshall sitting in his car looking directly at the camera. He has a greying beard and dark hair. His right arm is on the open window of the car, which is black. A parking garage is blurred in the background behind him.
Gavin Marshall said the charges were "extortionate"

Back inside the charged drop-off area, a multi-storey car park provides a roof and shade from the warm afternoon sun.

Gavin Marshall, 45, has been waiting for some time for his in-laws to arrive on a flight from London, before driving them back to Stirling.

He says he had not noticed the charge before he parked up.

He says: "It's a bit extortionate, £1 per minute is a bit of a joke."

"The flat £6 I think is fair, this £1 per minute seems a bit silly, it's a bit much."

Dean Carse smiling right at the camera while sitting in the cab of his taxi. He is wearing a grey polo shirt with a red and yellow logo on the upper right chest and left sleeve. He has dark curly hair and a short, dark bear. Part of a tattoo is visible on his upper right arm, which is resting on the dashboard.
Dean Carse said the charges made each journey £6 more expensive for customers in his taxi

Meanwhile, taxi driver Dean Carse, 31, says the charge has an impact on customers.

He says: "Every journey is £6 more expensive.

"I pay it, but I get it back off the customer, which is ridiculous, it goes from the customer to me to the airport.

"The airport spin it like they care about pollution, but they don't. They're a business and they want to make money."

Edinburgh Airport declined to comment when contacted by BBC News, but said that a free drop-off area was available.

They added that passengers could choose whether to use the free or paid areas.

The industry body, Airports UK, said all hubs offered free drop-off options further from the terminals.

It said "park and ride" facilities where people can leave their car and take a bus to the airport were provided.

A Police Scotland spokesperson said it regularly gave "advice" to motorists in the airport complex, but was unable to be specific on what that was.

They added: "Where necessary, appropriate action will be taken."

High on snus in school: The hidden nicotine pouches shredding teens' gums

Getty Images A man shows the camera a small container of nicotine pouches, which look like very small pillows. He is wearing a blue button-down shirt and standing outside. Getty Images

Finn picks up a small, white, teabag-like pouch from a round, brightly coloured tin and places it between his upper lip and gum.

He and his mates use nicotine pouches until they vomit, he tells me.

The strength of the nicotine - at 150mg a pouch - is enough, he says, to "immobilise" them - especially when they use two or three in one go.

"It's the burn at first," the 17-year-old explains. "You feel this burning sensation against your gums, and then you get the hit."

The hit, he says, is far stronger than any cigarette, and often he and his friends will lie down before they put the pouch in place, hidden under their lips.

Finn tells me how easy they are to use; they are so inconspicuous he even uses them at school.

"I've sat in class before and had one in my mouth that was so strong I was all over the place," he says. "I was sweating, salivating and struggling to concentrate."

In the end, he says, his teacher noticed he looked "bright green" and he made his excuses and bolted out of his maths lesson.

Finn, who only wants us to use his first name, is not boasting. In fact, he says, he regrets ever having started using pouches. He now sees himself as an addict and wants to warn others.

"I just got bored of vaping, and now I'm stuck on these."

Getty Images Nicotine pouches are shown in a container, with some spilled beside it on a light blue background. Getty Images

A growing number of young people are using nicotine pouches - some swapping from vaping or smoking, others trying nicotine for the first time.

Figures seen by BBC News suggest there has been nearly a four-fold rise in use by 16 to 24-year-olds in the UK - from less than than 1% in 2022, to 3.6% in 2024.

The pouches are widely sold online, in supermarkets and in corner shops. Priced at around £5 for a pack of 20, they come in exotic flavours with varying nicotine strengths - from 1.5mg to claims of 150mg for a more "extreme" experience.

Anyone can buy them. There is no minimum age as with cigarettes, vapes and alcohol. Nor is there any restriction on the strength of the nicotine in the pouches.

"I've heard of children as young as 11 or 12 nipping to shops and buying them," warns Kate Pike, Trading Standards' lead officer for tobacco and vaping.

She says her organisation is receiving an increasing number of reports from parents and teachers that nicotine pouches are being sold to children.

"It is incredibly frustrating that there is nothing we can currently do to prevent them."

What are nicotine pouches?

  • Also known as white snus, they contain nicotine extracted from tobacco leaves, sodium carbonate, flavourings, and sweeteners
  • They often have a high pH value, an effect of the ingredient sodium carbonate, which allows the nicotine inside the pouch to penetrate the soft lining on the gum more quickly and enter the bloodstream, resulting in stronger nicotine kicks

Source: Institute of Odontology, University of Gothenburg

Ms Pike is urging the government to prioritise the Tobacco and Vapes Bill, which, if passed, will make it illegal to sell these pouches to under 18s.

"We need to take action against those who either deliberately or uncaringly risk children getting hooked on a highly addictive product," she says.

Despite containing large amounts of the drug, nicotine pouches do not need to display the warning, "This product contains nicotine which is a highly addictive substance" on their packaging.

Kent Trading Standards Gloved hands hold a stack of tubs of nicotine pouches labelled with the word KillaKent Trading Standards
Kent Trading Standards' ports team seized a vanload of 66,000 tubs of nicotine pouches destined for the UK in February 2025

If the pouches have more than 16.7mg of nicotine, then under general product safety regulation, there should be a skull and cross bones symbol on the packaging and a list of the chemical components written in English.

This regulation, Ms Pike says, is increasingly being flouted, with Trading Standards officers seizing thousands of illegal products across the UK.

The pouches are significantly less harmful than cigarettes, and because chemicals do not enter the lungs, they may carry fewer risks than vapes.

Harry Tattan-Birch, a senior researcher from University College London, says pouches are the "least harmful way" to ingest nicotine.

"If they were used to stop people smoking or vaping, they could have a positive public health effect - but it would only be positive if they were used by those wanting to quit, not those who are trying nicotine for the first time."

While they may carry fewer health risks than cigarettes and vapes, there are cardiovascular risks for people using pouches with high quantities of nicotine - and there is growing concern over the damage nicotine pouches do to gums.

Finn has been using pouches for more than a year and says he reached a point where his "mouth was shredded to bits" and, on one occasion, he "peeled half [his] gum off".

Dr Patric Saraby, a Swedish dentist based in Bournemouth, has treated patients who are nicotine pouch users with gum lesions so deep it's possible to see the root of the tooth.

"The long-term damage of these products is extremely worrying," he says.

One of his patients, a 23-year-old student, started to develop lesions in his gums while studying for his exams. He was using five pouches a day to help him quit vaping and, he says, to help him focus on his studies.

"It started as a recreational thing, but it quickly took hold," the student says. "I became worried when a bit of my gum - where I had been placing the pouch - came off."

He's now nicotine-free and his gums are starting to heal after quitting vaping and pouches eight months ago.

Sintija Miļuna-Meldere Oral mucosal changes caused by nicotine pouchesSintija Miļuna-Meldere
White lesions caused by repeated nicotine pouches

Dr Saraby, who has carried out two years of research into nicotine pouches, says there is an increased risk of localised gum disease and localised bone loss.

He is worried that the "tidal wave of nicotine pouch use" that has hit Sweden - the home of the original, tobacco-based snus - will soon hit the UK. There, 25% of 16 to 29-year-olds are users and dentists are seeing increasing numbers of patients with painful inflammation that is taking months, sometimes years, to heal.

A five-year study has just started at the University of Gothenburg into why white snus is leaving such damage compared to the tobacco-based products.

Dr Gita Gale, a specialist in oral medicine who is leading the study, says it's "alarming" how many people are using this product given how little is known about the long-term consequences of its use.

The government says its "landmark" Tobacco and Vapes bill, which is currently making its way through the House of Lords, will ban the sale of nicotine pouches to under 18s and prevent vapes and nicotine products from being deliberately promoted and advertised to children.

"It will stop the next generation from getting hooked on nicotine and put an end to the cycle of addiction and disadvantage," a government spokesperson added.

Finn says many of his school friends have moved from vaping to nicotine pouches. He did the same but feels he has had enough, and is trying to cut back.

"All I could think about was how much I needed it - it got too much," Finn says. "Snus is so much harder to kick than vaping.

"My advice? Don't bother with any of it in the first place. Nicotine traps you."

Parades, flags and songs: The campaign to force Ukrainian children to love Russia

Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region Two teenaged girls lie on their stomachs in a gym hall aiming a gun. One is wearing army camos and the other all black. They are facing away from the camera. Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region
Russia's youth military organisation Yunarmia now operates in occupied regions of Ukraine, including Zaporizhzhia, where these girls live

Being taught to love Russia starts early for children in occupied areas of eastern Ukraine.

At a nursery school in Luhansk, more than 70 youngsters line up holding a long black and orange Russian military banner in the shape of a letter Z, the symbol of Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Across the city, seven little girls jump up and down and gesture in front of a Russian flag to the brash song "I am Russian" that blares out of loudspeakers. When the music stops they shout out together: "I'm Russian."

In an occupied town called Anthracite, nursery school children have made trench candles and blankets for Russian soldiers.

It is all part of a campaign that seeks not only to erase Ukraine's national identity, but also turn young Ukrainians against their own country.

To do that with children you need teachers, and as many Ukrainian teachers have fled, the government in Moscow has begun offering lump-sums of 2m roubles (£18,500) to Russian teaching staff willing to relocate to occupied parts of Ukraine.

The biggest and most powerful Russian organisation involved with children is Yunarmia (Youth Army).

Affiliated with the Russian defence ministry, it accepts members as young as eight. It operates across all of Russia, and now has branches in occupied areas of Ukraine.

"We're providing children with some basic skills which they'll find useful should they decide to join military service," says Fidail Bikbulatov, who runs Yunarmia's section in occupied areas of the Zaporizhzhia region in south-east Ukraine.

Bikbulatov was deployed from Russia's Bashkortostan, where he headed the "Youth Guard" division of the ruling United Russia party.

Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region A line of around ten boys stand in a football pitch, kneeling and aiming a gun. They are wearing khakis and white t-shirt. An adult dressed in army camos and a bullet proof vest looks on. he is wearing a balaclava and is armed with a large gun.Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region
Yunarmia has been sanctioned by both the UK and the EU for the "brainwashing" and "militarisation" of Ukrainian children

The EU has sanctioned Yunarmia, and Bikbulatov personally, for "the militarisation of Ukrainian children". Yunarmia is also targeted by UK sanctions for being part of Russia's campaign of "brainwashing" Ukrainian children.

Yunarmia is not alone. Other Russian state-sponsored organisations that have moved in include "Movement of the First Ones" and "Warrior", a network of centres for "the military and athletic training, and patriotic education of young people" set up on Russian President Vladimir Putin's orders.

These groups organise competitions such as Zarnitsa games rooted in the Soviet era, where Ukrainian children are required to demonstrate "general military literacy, knowledge of Russian statehood and military history, firearms firing skills".

As the children progress through the education system, they are taught in Russian, using the Russian curriculum and textbooks that justify Russia's war against Ukraine.

One such book portrays Ukraine as little more than a Western invention created to spite Russia, and argues that human civilisation would have possibly ended had Russia not invaded Ukraine in 2022.

Lisa, who attended a school in occupied Donetsk, says students there were forced to take part in events celebrating Russia and the USSR.

"When they were preparing a parade of some sort, I, the whole of my class and the whole of my year were forced to attend every weekend and train. We had to hold posters. I could not say no, it wasn't my choice. I was told I had to do it to graduate," Lisa says.

"Every time lessons started, our teacher made us stand up, put a hand on our hearts and listen to the Russian anthem, which she made us learn by heart, too."

Lisa now lives in the US and has been posting about her experiences on TikTok.

EPA A crowd of young children in Moscow, face away from the camera wearing the Yunarmia uniform: a red polo and beige khakis, as well a a red beret. The girls are wearing large white scrunchies. EPA
Thousands of Ukrainian children have been taken on tours of Russia and many do not return

Serving Russian soldiers also play a role in the campaign of indoctrination, visiting schools to give so-called "bravery lessons". They glorify their exploits at war and depict Ukrainian forces as violent, unruly neo-Nazis.

Pavel Tropkin, an official from the ruling United Russia party now based in the occupied part of Kherson region, says these lessons are held "so that children understand the objectives" of what the Kremlin calls "the special military operation" in Ukraine.

Outside school, Ukrainian children are taken to see specially organised exhibitions glorifying Russia and the "special military operation".

One centre catering for such trips is hosting exhibitions called "Russia - My History" and "Special Military Operation Heroes" in Melitopol in Zaporizhzhia region.

The trips do not stop there.

The Kremlin has also launched a big campaign to take Ukrainian children on tours of Russia as part of efforts to instil pro-Russian sentiments.

Russia's culture minister Olga Lyubimova claims that more than 20,000 children from occupied Ukrainian territories have been taken to Russia under one programme alone, called "4+85". According to the Russian government's concert agency Rosconcert, which runs the programme, it seeks to "integrate the new generation into a unified Russian society".

However, Russia's "integration" campaign goes far beyond indoctrination.

Thousands of Ukrainian children taken to Russia during the three years of the full-scale invasion have not been allowed to return.

According to the Ukrainian government, more than 19,000 Ukrainian children have been forcibly deported to Russia. The UK government estimates that some 6,000 Ukrainian children have been relocated to a network of "re-education camps" in Russia.

International humanitarian law bans activities like this. For example, the Fourth Geneva Convention says that an occupying power may not enlist children "in formations or organizations subordinate to it" and that it may apply "no pressure or propaganda which aims at securing voluntary enlistment" of locals in occupied areas into its armed or auxiliary forces.

In 2023, the ICC issued an arrest warrant for President Putin, in part for the unlawful deportation of children. Putin and his government deny the charges.

Waging its war on Ukraine, Russia is not only after territory. It is also trying to put its stamp on the people who live there, no matter how young they are.

'Inquiry after SAS identities leaked' and 'brat & groom'

BBC "Inquiry after SAS identities leaked online" reads the headline on the front page of The Sunday Times.BBC
The army has launched an inquiry into the leaking of SAS identities as Defence Secretary John Healey is left "furious" over the breach, writes The Sunday Times. There were "100 arrests in umbrella protests for Palestine Action" it reports, with a splash of two women being accompanied by police officers under an umbrella. The King's residence at Highgrove "suffered an exodus of gardeners" who The Times writes were "complaining about the monarch's demands and low staff pay". A statement from the King's Foundation reported "high satisfaction rates among staff at the charity".
"Tell the truth on my son's murder" reads the headline on the front page of the Daily Mirror.
The father of Stephen Lawrence, the man murdered at a bus stop in 1993, gives an exclusive interview to the Daily Mirror ahead of the parole hearing of one of his son's killer's. "Tell the truth on my son's murder" reads the tabloid's headline. The Mirror have another exclusive on their front page with John Torode's wife Lisa Faulkner, following the MasterChef presenter's sacking.
"You mugs!" reads the headline on the front page of the Daily Star.
Here come the "brat & groom" writes the Daily Star as lime green maven Charli XCX wears white. Also on the Star's front page, actor Danny Dyer calls for working class leaders and names Sir Keir Starmer a "non-entity".
"Middle class face higher water bills" reads the headline on the front page of The Daily Telegraph.
"Middle class face higher water bills" reads the headline on the front page of The Daily Telegraph. Labour MPs "will be urged to introduce a nationwide scheme that would see poorer families given huge discounts on their charges". As part of the government's new RHSE curriculum, "pupils to be taught that 'feeling down' is not a mental health condition". Also in education news, teachers say "antisemitic abuse rife in schools". Elsewhere on the Telegraph's front, Chancellor Rachel Reeves could see a £5bn windfall "from seized Bitcoins" to help her "fill the black hole in the public finances".
"Top Starmer mandarin's firm is paid for 'spy ops" reads the headline on the front page of The Mail on Sunday.
The Mail on Sunday runs with an exclusive on the National Security Adviser Johnathan Powell, saying his firm is paid for "spy ops". The "Tories demand inquiry" over the "secret taxpayer-funded talks with "rogue states", it writes.
"NHS 'tourists' fleecing our hospitals for £200m" reads the headline on the front page of the Sunday Express.
"NHS 'tourists' fleecing our hospitals" writes the Sunday Express. Citing new figures, the paper reports that people coming from abroad have "deprived the cash-strapped NHS of a staggering £200m over the past five years".
News Daily banner

Sign up for our morning newsletter and get BBC News in your inbox.

News Daily banner

Members only: India's rich and famous ditch old-school clubs for exclusive hangouts

Soho House A man and a woman at a club having a drink and engaged in an animated chat. The man is wearing a checked shirt with sunglasses while the woman is wearing a black dress with glasses. Soho House
A modern avatar of the private members-only club has emerged as India births new millionaires

For decades, the Indian elite have sought escape in Raj-era private clubs and gymkhanas, scattered around the swankiest neighbourhoods in the country's big cities, hillside resorts and cantonment towns.

Access to these quintessentially "English" enclaves, with their bellboys, butlers, dark mahogany interiors and rigid dress codes, has been reserved for the privileged; the old moneyed who roam the corridors of power - think business tycoons, senior bureaucrats, erstwhile royals, politicians or officers of the armed forces.

This is where India's rich and powerful have hobnobbed for years, building social capital over cigars or squash and brokering business deals during golf sessions. Today, these spaces can feel strangely anachronistic - relics of a bygone era in a country eager to shed its colonial past.

As Asia's third largest economy breeds a new generation of wealth creators, a more modern and less formal avatar of the private members-only club - that reflects the sweeping economic and demographic changes under way in India - is emerging. This is where the newly well-heeled are hanging out and doing business.

Getty Images Image of the Bombay Gymkhana, a lush green cricket club famous for its iconic pavilion and open cricket ground. Getty Images
Raj-era private clubs and gymkhanas have been the playgrounds for India's privileged for decades
Getty Images A vintage black and white photo of Parsi Gymkhana in Marine Lines in Mumbai, IndiaGetty Images
India's rich and powerful have hobnobbed for years in old colonial clubs to socialise and do business

Demand for such spaces is strong enough for the international chain Soho House to plan two new launches in the capital Delhi and in south Mumbai in the coming months. Their first offering - an ocean-facing club on Mumbai's iconic Juhu Beach - opened six years ago and is wildly successful.

The chain is one of a host of new club entrants vying to cater to a market that is booming in India.

Soho House started in London in the mid-90s as an antidote to the upscale gentlemen's clubs that lined Pall Mall. It came in as a refreshingly new concept: a more relaxed club for creators, thinkers and creative entrepreneurs, who might have felt like they didn't belong in the enclaves of the old aristocracy.

Thirty years later, India's flourishing tech-driven economy of start-ups and creators has birthed a nouveau riche that's afforded Soho House exactly another such market opportunity.

"There's growth in India's young wealth, and young entrepreneurs really need a foundation to platform themselves," Kelly Wardingham, Soho House's Asia regional director, told the BBC. The "new wealthy require different things" from what the traditional gymkhanas offer.

Unlike the old clubs, Soho House does not either "shut off" or let in people based on their family legacy, status, wealth or gender, she says. Members use the space as a haven to escape the bustle of Mumbai, with its rooftop pool, gym and private screening rooms as well as a plethora of gourmet food options. But they also use it to drive value from a diverse community of potential mentors and investors, or to learn new skills and attend events and seminars.

Reema Maya, a young filmmaker, says her membership of the house in Mumbai - a city "where one is always jostling for space and a quiet corner in a cramped cafe" - has given her rare access to the movers and shakers of Mumbai's film industry - which might otherwise have been impossible for someone like her "without generational privilege".

In fact, for years, traditional gymkhanas were closed off for the creative community. The famous Bollywood actor, the late Feroz Khan, once asked a gymkhana club in Mumbai for membership, only to be politely refused, as they didn't admit actors.

Khan, taken aback by their snootiness, is said to have quipped, "If you'd watched my movies, you would know I am not much of an actor."

By contrast, Soho House proudly flaunts Bollywood star Ali Fazal, a member, on its in-house magazine cover.

Soho House The image shows a roof-top room at Soho House club, overlooking the expanse of the Arabian sea. Soho House
Soho House's ocean-facing club on Mumbai's iconic Juhu Beach opened six years ago and is wildly successful

But beyond just a more modern, democratic ethos, high demand for these clubs is also a factor of the limited supply of the traditional gymkhanas, which are still very sought after.

Waiting queues at most of them can extend "up to many years," and supply hasn't caught up to serve the country's "new crop of self-made businessmen, creative geniuses and high-flying corporate honchos", according to Ankit Kansal of Axon Developers, which recently released a report on the rise of new members-only clubs.

This mismatch has led to more than two dozen new club entrants - including independent ones like Quorum and BVLD, as well as those backed by global hospitality brands like St Regis and Four Seasons - opening in India. At least half a dozen more are on their way in the next few years, according to Axon Developers.

This market, the report says, is growing at nearly 10% every year, with Covid having become a big turning point, as the wealthy chose to avoid public spaces.

While these spaces mark significant shifts, with their progressive membership policies and patronage of the arts, literary and independent music scene they are very much still "sanctums of modern luxury", says Axon, with admission given out by invite only or through referrals, and costing several times more than the monthly income of most Indians.

At Soho House for instance, annual membership is 320,000 Indian rupees ($3,700; $2,775) - beyond what most people can afford.

What's changed is that membership is based on personal accomplishment and future potential rather than family pedigree. A new self-made elite has replaced the old inheritors - but access remains largely out of reach for the average middle-class Indian.

AFP via Getty Images Media personnel gather near a red Tesla 'Model Y' vehicle during the inauguration of India's first Tesla showroom, in Mumbai on July 15, 2025. AFP via Getty Images
India's luxury market has boomed, even as the high street struggles with tepid demand

In a way the rising take-up for these memberships reflects India's broader post-liberalisation growth story – when the country opened up to the world and discarded its socialist moorings.

Growth galloped, but the rich became the biggest beneficiaries, growing even richer as inequality reached gaping proportions. It's why the country's luxury market has boomed, even as the high street struggles with tepid demand, with most Indians without money to spend on anything beyond the basics.

But growing numbers of newly-minted rich present a big business opportunity.

India's 797,000 high-net worth individuals are set to double in number within a couple of years - a fraction of a population of 1.4 billion, but enough to drive future growth for those building new playgrounds for the wealthy to unwind, network and live the high life.

Follow BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, X and Facebook.

Anti-immigrant rallies staged across Poland

EPA/Shutterstock People take part in an anti-immigration protest in Warsaw, Poland. Photo: 19 July 2025EPA/Shutterstock

Anti‑immigration protests have taken place in dozens of towns and cities across Poland.

Most demonstrations attracted several hundred people or fewer on Saturday - but police estimated that about 3,000 took part in the largest rally in the southern city of Katowice.

The protests were organised by far-right political group Konfederacja, and another nationalist organisation.

Politicians from Konfederacja and the opposition Law and Justice party have been warning about a flood of illegal migration in Poland - but official figures do not support their claims.

"Without closing Poland to illegal immigration, without starting deportation campaigns, without abandoning political correctness... security will gradually deteriorate," Konfederacja co-chairman Krzysztof Bosak told the crowd in the eastern city of Bialystok.

A minute's silence was held at some gatherings in memory of a 24-year-old Polish woman murdered in the central city of Torun.

In the capital Warsaw, rival rallies took place just metres away. There were no reports of violence.

Police have since arrested a Venezuelan man in the case.

Right-wing politicians claim Poland is in danger of being flooded by illegal migrants.

Immigration has increased over the last decade - but official figures show that migration is lower so far this year than in previous years.

Earlier this month, Poland introduced checks on its borders with Germany and Lithuania after Berlin began turning away asylum seekers. Germany introduced its own controls on the Polish and Czech borders in 2023.

In March, Poland temporarily suspended the right of migrants arriving in the country via its border with Belarus to apply for asylum.

Parades, flags and songs: The campaign to force Ukrainian children to love Russia

Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region Two teenaged girls lie on their stomachs in a gym hall aiming a gun. One is wearing army camos and the other all black. They are facing away from the camera. Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region
Russia's youth military organisation Yunarmia now operates in occupied regions of Ukraine, including Zaporizhzhia, where these girls live

Being taught to love Russia starts early for children in occupied areas of eastern Ukraine.

At a nursery school in Luhansk, more than 70 youngsters line up holding a long black and orange Russian military banner in the shape of a letter Z, the symbol of Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Across the city, seven little girls jump up and down and gesture in front of a Russian flag to the brash song "I am Russian" that blares out of loudspeakers. When the music stops they shout out together: "I'm Russian."

In an occupied town called Anthracite, nursery school children have made trench candles and blankets for Russian soldiers.

It is all part of a campaign that seeks not only to erase Ukraine's national identity, but also turn young Ukrainians against their own country.

To do that with children you need teachers, and as many Ukrainian teachers have fled, the government in Moscow has begun offering lump-sums of 2m roubles (£18,500) to Russian teaching staff willing to relocate to occupied parts of Ukraine.

The biggest and most powerful Russian organisation involved with children is Yunarmia (Youth Army).

Affiliated with the Russian defence ministry, it accepts members as young as eight. It operates across all of Russia, and now has branches in occupied areas of Ukraine.

"We're providing children with some basic skills which they'll find useful should they decide to join military service," says Fidail Bikbulatov, who runs Yunarmia's section in occupied areas of the Zaporizhzhia region in south-east Ukraine.

Bikbulatov was deployed from Russia's Bashkortostan, where he headed the "Youth Guard" division of the ruling United Russia party.

Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region A line of around ten boys stand in a football pitch, kneeling and aiming a gun. They are wearing khakis and white t-shirt. An adult dressed in army camos and a bullet proof vest looks on. he is wearing a balaclava and is armed with a large gun.Yunarmia branch of the Zaporizhzhya region
Yunarmia has been sanctioned by both the UK and the EU for the "brainwashing" and "militarisation" of Ukrainian children

The EU has sanctioned Yunarmia, and Bikbulatov personally, for "the militarisation of Ukrainian children". Yunarmia is also targeted by UK sanctions for being part of Russia's campaign of "brainwashing" Ukrainian children.

Yunarmia is not alone. Other Russian state-sponsored organisations that have moved in include "Movement of the First Ones" and "Warrior", a network of centres for "the military and athletic training, and patriotic education of young people" set up on Russian President Vladimir Putin's orders.

These groups organise competitions such as Zarnitsa games rooted in the Soviet era, where Ukrainian children are required to demonstrate "general military literacy, knowledge of Russian statehood and military history, firearms firing skills".

As the children progress through the education system, they are taught in Russian, using the Russian curriculum and textbooks that justify Russia's war against Ukraine.

One such book portrays Ukraine as little more than a Western invention created to spite Russia, and argues that human civilisation would have possibly ended had Russia not invaded Ukraine in 2022.

Lisa, who attended a school in occupied Donetsk, says students there were forced to take part in events celebrating Russia and the USSR.

"When they were preparing a parade of some sort, I, the whole of my class and the whole of my year were forced to attend every weekend and train. We had to hold posters. I could not say no, it wasn't my choice. I was told I had to do it to graduate," Lisa says.

"Every time lessons started, our teacher made us stand up, put a hand on our hearts and listen to the Russian anthem, which she made us learn by heart, too."

Lisa now lives in the US and has been posting about her experiences on TikTok.

EPA A crowd of young children in Moscow, face away from the camera wearing the Yunarmia uniform: a red polo and beige khakis, as well a a red beret. The girls are wearing large white scrunchies. EPA
Thousands of Ukrainian children have been taken on tours of Russia and many do not return

Serving Russian soldiers also play a role in the campaign of indoctrination, visiting schools to give so-called "bravery lessons". They glorify their exploits at war and depict Ukrainian forces as violent, unruly neo-Nazis.

Pavel Tropkin, an official from the ruling United Russia party now based in the occupied part of Kherson region, says these lessons are held "so that children understand the objectives" of what the Kremlin calls "the special military operation" in Ukraine.

Outside school, Ukrainian children are taken to see specially organised exhibitions glorifying Russia and the "special military operation".

One centre catering for such trips is hosting exhibitions called "Russia - My History" and "Special Military Operation Heroes" in Melitopol in Zaporizhzhia region.

The trips do not stop there.

The Kremlin has also launched a big campaign to take Ukrainian children on tours of Russia as part of efforts to instil pro-Russian sentiments.

Russia's culture minister Olga Lyubimova claims that more than 20,000 children from occupied Ukrainian territories have been taken to Russia under one programme alone, called "4+85". According to the Russian government's concert agency Rosconcert, which runs the programme, it seeks to "integrate the new generation into a unified Russian society".

However, Russia's "integration" campaign goes far beyond indoctrination.

Thousands of Ukrainian children taken to Russia during the three years of the full-scale invasion have not been allowed to return.

According to the Ukrainian government, more than 19,000 Ukrainian children have been forcibly deported to Russia. The UK government estimates that some 6,000 Ukrainian children have been relocated to a network of "re-education camps" in Russia.

International humanitarian law bans activities like this. For example, the Fourth Geneva Convention says that an occupying power may not enlist children "in formations or organizations subordinate to it" and that it may apply "no pressure or propaganda which aims at securing voluntary enlistment" of locals in occupied areas into its armed or auxiliary forces.

In 2023, the ICC issued an arrest warrant for President Putin, in part for the unlawful deportation of children. Putin and his government deny the charges.

Waging its war on Ukraine, Russia is not only after territory. It is also trying to put its stamp on the people who live there, no matter how young they are.

Members only: India's rich and famous ditch old-school clubs for exclusive hangouts

Soho House A man and a woman at a club having a drink and engaged in an animated chat. The man is wearing a checked shirt with sunglasses while the woman is wearing a black dress with glasses. Soho House
A modern avatar of the private members-only club has emerged as India births new millionaires

For decades, the Indian elite have sought escape in Raj-era private clubs and gymkhanas, scattered around the swankiest neighbourhoods in the country's big cities, hillside resorts and cantonment towns.

Access to these quintessentially "English" enclaves, with their bellboys, butlers, dark mahogany interiors and rigid dress codes, has been reserved for the privileged; the old moneyed who roam the corridors of power - think business tycoons, senior bureaucrats, erstwhile royals, politicians or officers of the armed forces.

This is where India's rich and powerful have hobnobbed for years, building social capital over cigars or squash and brokering business deals during golf sessions. Today, these spaces can feel strangely anachronistic - relics of a bygone era in a country eager to shed its colonial past.

As Asia's third largest economy breeds a new generation of wealth creators, a more modern and less formal avatar of the private members-only club - that reflects the sweeping economic and demographic changes under way in India - is emerging. This is where the newly well-heeled are hanging out and doing business.

Getty Images Image of the Bombay Gymkhana, a lush green cricket club famous for its iconic pavilion and open cricket ground. Getty Images
Raj-era private clubs and gymkhanas have been the playgrounds for India's privileged for decades
Getty Images A vintage black and white photo of Parsi Gymkhana in Marine Lines in Mumbai, IndiaGetty Images
India's rich and powerful have hobnobbed for years in old colonial clubs to socialise and do business

Demand for such spaces is strong enough for the international chain Soho House to plan two new launches in the capital Delhi and in south Mumbai in the coming months. Their first offering - an ocean-facing club on Mumbai's iconic Juhu Beach - opened six years ago and is wildly successful.

The chain is one of a host of new club entrants vying to cater to a market that is booming in India.

Soho House started in London in the mid-90s as an antidote to the upscale gentlemen's clubs that lined Pall Mall. It came in as a refreshingly new concept: a more relaxed club for creators, thinkers and creative entrepreneurs, who might have felt like they didn't belong in the enclaves of the old aristocracy.

Thirty years later, India's flourishing tech-driven economy of start-ups and creators has birthed a nouveau riche that's afforded Soho House exactly another such market opportunity.

"There's growth in India's young wealth, and young entrepreneurs really need a foundation to platform themselves," Kelly Wardingham, Soho House's Asia regional director, told the BBC. The "new wealthy require different things" from what the traditional gymkhanas offer.

Unlike the old clubs, Soho House does not either "shut off" or let in people based on their family legacy, status, wealth or gender, she says. Members use the space as a haven to escape the bustle of Mumbai, with its rooftop pool, gym and private screening rooms as well as a plethora of gourmet food options. But they also use it to drive value from a diverse community of potential mentors and investors, or to learn new skills and attend events and seminars.

Reema Maya, a young filmmaker, says her membership of the house in Mumbai - a city "where one is always jostling for space and a quiet corner in a cramped cafe" - has given her rare access to the movers and shakers of Mumbai's film industry - which might otherwise have been impossible for someone like her "without generational privilege".

In fact, for years, traditional gymkhanas were closed off for the creative community. The famous Bollywood actor, the late Feroz Khan, once asked a gymkhana club in Mumbai for membership, only to be politely refused, as they didn't admit actors.

Khan, taken aback by their snootiness, is said to have quipped, "If you'd watched my movies, you would know I am not much of an actor."

By contrast, Soho House proudly flaunts Bollywood star Ali Fazal, a member, on its in-house magazine cover.

Soho House The image shows a roof-top room at Soho House club, overlooking the expanse of the Arabian sea. Soho House
Soho House's ocean-facing club on Mumbai's iconic Juhu Beach opened six years ago and is wildly successful

But beyond just a more modern, democratic ethos, high demand for these clubs is also a factor of the limited supply of the traditional gymkhanas, which are still very sought after.

Waiting queues at most of them can extend "up to many years," and supply hasn't caught up to serve the country's "new crop of self-made businessmen, creative geniuses and high-flying corporate honchos", according to Ankit Kansal of Axon Developers, which recently released a report on the rise of new members-only clubs.

This mismatch has led to more than two dozen new club entrants - including independent ones like Quorum and BVLD, as well as those backed by global hospitality brands like St Regis and Four Seasons - opening in India. At least half a dozen more are on their way in the next few years, according to Axon Developers.

This market, the report says, is growing at nearly 10% every year, with Covid having become a big turning point, as the wealthy chose to avoid public spaces.

While these spaces mark significant shifts, with their progressive membership policies and patronage of the arts, literary and independent music scene they are very much still "sanctums of modern luxury", says Axon, with admission given out by invite only or through referrals, and costing several times more than the monthly income of most Indians.

At Soho House for instance, annual membership is 320,000 Indian rupees ($3,700; $2,775) - beyond what most people can afford.

What's changed is that membership is based on personal accomplishment and future potential rather than family pedigree. A new self-made elite has replaced the old inheritors - but access remains largely out of reach for the average middle-class Indian.

AFP via Getty Images Media personnel gather near a red Tesla 'Model Y' vehicle during the inauguration of India's first Tesla showroom, in Mumbai on July 15, 2025. AFP via Getty Images
India's luxury market has boomed, even as the high street struggles with tepid demand

In a way the rising take-up for these memberships reflects India's broader post-liberalisation growth story – when the country opened up to the world and discarded its socialist moorings.

Growth galloped, but the rich became the biggest beneficiaries, growing even richer as inequality reached gaping proportions. It's why the country's luxury market has boomed, even as the high street struggles with tepid demand, with most Indians without money to spend on anything beyond the basics.

But growing numbers of newly-minted rich present a big business opportunity.

India's 797,000 high-net worth individuals are set to double in number within a couple of years - a fraction of a population of 1.4 billion, but enough to drive future growth for those building new playgrounds for the wealthy to unwind, network and live the high life.

Follow BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, X and Facebook.

More than 100 arrests over Palestine Action ban protests

BBC Police arrest a woman in Parliament Square, LondonBBC
Police made more than 50 arrests in Parliament Square in central London

Dozens of people have been arrested at protests across the UK against the decision to proscribe Palestine Action as a terror group.

Arrests have been reported in London, Edinburgh, Manchester, Bristol and Truro, all places where demonstrations in support of the pro-Palestine action group took place on Saturday.

The Met Police said 55 people were arrested on suspicion of terrorism offences in Westminster for displaying placards in support of Palestine Action. Eight were arrested in Truro in Cornwall.

The government proscribed the group earlier this month under the Terrorism Act of 2000, making membership of or support for the group a criminal offence, following a break-in at an RAF base.

Across the country, protesters held placards with the words: "I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action."

In London, arrests were made near the Mahatma Gandhi statue in Parliament Square, where as many as 20 police vans attended.

Officers moved in swiftly to arrest those holding the placards, many of whom appeared to be over the age of 60.

One woman claimed to be in her 80s and was walking with a stick. Some were led away while others had to be carried.

Devon and Cornwall Police said two men and six women were arrested on suspicion of terrorism offences after protesters gathered near Truro Cathedral.

The force said around 30 people were involved in the peaceful demonstration, organised by campaign group Defend Our Juries.

Earlier, the campaign group said that one of those arrested near the cathedral was an 81-year-old former magistrate.

It also said 16 people were arrested in Manchester.

Police forces in the other locations where protests took place have not yet confirmed the number of arrests they made.

EPA Police officers carry a person in handcuffs away from Parliament SquareEPA
Some demonstrators in London were led away while others had to be carried by officers

Saturday's protests came ahead of a High Court hearing on Monday at which the co-founder of Palestine Action, Huda Ammori, will ask for permission to challenge the decision to ban the group.

Last Saturday, 71 arrests were made across the UK at similar protests against the decision.

Palestine Action has engaged in activities that have predominantly targeted arms companies since the start of the current war in Gaza.

MPs voted to proscribe the group after activists broke into RAF Brize Norton in June, spraying two Voyager aircraft with red paint and causing £7m worth of damage. Palestine Action took responsibility for the incident at the time.

Four people have since been remanded in custody, charged with conspiracy to commit criminal damage and conspiracy to enter a prohibited place knowingly for a purpose prejudicial to the safety or interests of the UK.

The incident also prompted a security review across all UK military bases.

Usyk blows Dubois away to reclaim undisputed crown

Usyk blows Dubois away to reclaim undisputed crown

Oleksandr Usyk lands a left hand on Daniel DuboisImage source, Queensberry
Image caption,

Oleksandr Usyk (right) has won all four fights as a professional on UK soil

Oleksandr Usyk further cemented his place as one of boxing's greats by stopping Daniel Dubois in round five to become a two-time undisputed heavyweight champion.

The Ukrainian put on a masterclass in front of 90,000 fans at Wembley Stadium to dash Dubois' dreams of being the first Briton to unify the division in the four-belt era.

Usyk, 38, put Dubois down twice in the fifth and the Londoner was unable to return to beat the count the second time round.

He also stopped Dubois in 2023 and extends his perfect record as a professional to 24 victories.

"I'm sorry [Dubois], it's sport. My people wanted this win," Usyk told DAZN.

"Nothing is next. It's enough. Next, I want to rest. My family, my wife, my children, I want to rest now. Two or three months, I want to just rest."

Dubois – who beat Anthony Joshua to defend his IBF title in September – tastes defeat for the third time in 25 contests as a professional, with each of those losses coming inside the distance.

Usyk reclaimed the IBF title, which was stripped from him just weeks after unifying the division in 2023, and added it to his WBA (Super), WBO and WBC belts.

"I have to commend him on the performance, I gave everything I had. Take no credit away from that man, I'll be back," Dubois told DAZN.

"I was just fighting, trying to pick up round by round. It is what it is."

Usyk still top of the heavyweight pile

Daniel Dubois on the canvas with Oleksandr Usyk standing over himImage source, Queensberry
Image caption,

Usyk has now won all 13 of his world title fights across two divisions

The great and good of the boxing world turned out to watch the momentous occasion, with Roy Jones Jr and Frank Bruno among those at ringside.

WBO interim heavyweight champion Joseph Parker was also keeping a close eye on proceedings as he seeks a date with Usyk next.

Usyk, who has called the UK his second home, was welcomed warmly after Dubois had also been cheered to the ring.

It took no time for the fight to spark into life as Dubois doubled up on his jab but it was clear that Usyk wasn't going to be a sitting target. The former undisputed cruiserweight champion was far too slick, ducking under the jab and punishing Dubois regularly.

Southpaw Usyk punctuated each of the opening two rounds with a counter left and had Dubois looking a little unsteady in the second.

Dubois looked out of the ring to his father Stan between rounds for some advice but he still found it difficult to pin down the 2012 Olympic gold medallist.

Usyk unloaded in the fifth and sent Dubois tumbling to the canvas with a crisp left.

Dubois showed incredible spirit to beat the count but the writing was already on the wall.

Another trusty left hook landed clean on Dubois' chin and his corner threw in the towel as the referee reached the count of nine.

Dubois left with another rebuilding job

Oleksandr Usyk holds his four world titlesImage source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Usyk has now beaten Anthony Joshua, Tyson Fury and Daniel Dubois twice

A third career defeat leaves Dubois in a difficult position and requiring another rebuild.

Dubois, 27, has not beaten a champion to claim a world title – he won the interim IBF belt and was subsequently elevated to full world champion before making one defence against Joshua.

Following his last defeat by Usyk, Dubois re-emerged with a newfound confidence but this loss will knock him back several steps.

He will have no shortage of options with the likes of interim WBC champion Agit Kabayel, WBA 'Regular' champion Kubrat Pulev or even the likes of Deontay Wilder to go after.

Usyk, meanwhile, is the A side in boxing's glamour division and has his pick of the bunch.

"Maybe it's Tyson Fury. Maybe we have three choices, Derek Chisora and Anthony Joshua, maybe Joseph Parker," Usyk told DAZN.

Dubois' team raised concerns over Usyk's age during fight week but he looked as good as ever.

As he has done in all previous rematches – against Fury and Joshua – Usyk used the data he had downloaded from the first encounter to his advantage.

Related topics

More boxing from the BBC

Sewage discharges to halve by 2030, minister pledges

PA Media Environment Secretary Steve Reed. He is smiling and wearing a navy blue suit jacket with a white collared shirtPA Media

The number of times sewage is discharged by water companies will be halved by 2030, the environment secretary has pledged.

Steve Reed's vow marks the first time ministers have set a clear target on the issue, following public outcry over the pollution incidents.

It comes after data published by the Environment Agency on Friday showed serious pollution incidents by water companies in England rose by 60% in 2024 to the highest number on record.

Reed said families had "watched their local rivers, coastlines and lakes suffer from record levels of pollution" - but the Conservatives said Labour had "done nothing to stop water bill rises" despite "big promises" to reform the system.

The pledge forms part of wider government plans to improve the water sector, ahead of a landmark Water Commission review of the industry due to be published on Monday.

The plans announced on Sunday will also include a commitment to work with devolved governments across the UK to ban wet wipes containing plastic, among other measures.

Reed is also expected to confirm aims to cut phosphorus pollution from treated wastewater - which causes algae blooms that are harmful to wildlife - in half by 2028, compared to 2024 levels.

There has been widespread scrutiny of water companies over the increasing number of sewage discharges into UK waterways amid rising bills - all while the firms have paid out millions to executives and shareholders.

The Environment Agency said water companies recorded 2,801 pollution incidents in 2024, up from 2,174 in 2023.

Of those, 75 were considered to pose "serious or persistent" harm to fisheries, drinking water and human health - up from 47 last year.

At the same time, water bosses in England were paid £7.6m in bonuses, according to the government. In June, it barred them from being paid out at six firms that had fallen foul of environmental and consumer standards.

The Water Commission's chair will lay out his recommendations on how to improve the environmental and financial performance of the sector. The government will respond in Parliament.

Several UK media outlets reported on Friday that the report would suggest scrapping the regulator, Ofwat, altogether. A government spokesperson said it would not comment on speculation.

England has a combined sewage system, which means both rainfall and sewage are processed through the same system. Last year, rainfall levels were up, which could have overwhelmed some water company infrastructure.

However, despite variations in rainfall, discharges that result in serious pollution are a breach of their permits and legal obligations.

Many incidents are reported to the Environment Agency by the companies themselves, but of 4,000 inspections carried out last year by the regulator, nearly a quarter of sites were in breach of their permits.

A record £104bn is due to be invested into the water sector over the next five years to improve its infrastructure.

As a result, consumer bills are expected to rise on average by £123 annually - though for Southern Water customers this could be as much as £224.

The Environment Agency has also received £189m to support hundreds of enforcement offices to inspect and prosecute water companies, with the fines retroactively paying for this.

Conservative shadow environment secretary Victoria Atkins said the government "must be transparent about where the £104bn investment is coming from as some will come through customer bill rises".

She said plans "must also include credible proposals to improve the water system's resilience to droughts, without placing an additional burden on bill payers and taxpayers".

Rain and thunderstorm alerts bring flash flood threat

Getty Images Woman walking in heavy rain holding a jacket over her head.Getty Images

Parts of the UK are braced for potentially dangerous flash flooding as thunderstorms and torrential rain are set arrive over the weekend.

The Met Office has issued an amber weather warning for south-east England as more than a month's worth of rain is forecast to fall in a matter of hours on Saturday morning.

It says fast-flowing and deep floodwaters are likely, leading to road and transport disruption, as well as power cuts.

The torrential downpours come days after a third UK heatwave of the year that parched swathes of the UK and led to several hosepipe bans being declared.

This will make flooding more likely and severe as the dry ground will not be able to absorb as much water.

The amber warning covers a stretch of the south coast, London and Cambridge, and is in force from 04:00 BST to 11:00 on Saturday.

Between 20 and 40mm of rain could fall within an hour in this area, the Met Office has warned, which could accumulate to 70-100mm in just a few hours.

It said homes and businesses are likely to be flooded, which will happen "quickly", while this amount of surface water will make driving difficult and may lead to road closures.

Lightning strikes, hail and strong winds may also cause train and bus cancellations.

Yellow weather warnings will cover the rest of eastern, central and northern England and a portion of eastern Scotland. A yellow warning is already in force for parts of eastern England.

Amber warnings indicated there is an increased chance severe weather could affect people's day-to-day lives, including a potential danger to life. Yellow warnings are less severe.

The last amber warning over London was in January 2024, when Storm Henk hit parts of central England and Wales, according to the Met Office.

After arriving on Friday night, the storm is forecast to move inland, pushing northwards across England on Saturday morning before arriving in Scotland by midday.

Yellow warnings for rain cover parts of England and Scotland on Sunday and Monday as residual parts of the storm linger.

Last weeks heatwave brought travel disruption, a number of water-related deaths and hosepipe bans being declared for millions living in Yorkshire, Kent and Sussex.

One might think a heavy dose of rainfall would help reduce these drought conditions - but because the rain will be very heavy in localised areas, it will run off the dry, baked earth rapidly, perhaps overwhelming local sewers and waterways.

A substantial recovery in reservoir and groundwater aquifer levels would require a more sustained spell of wet weather.

Yorkshire's hosepipe ban is expected to last until winter.

Thunderstorms following a heatwave in the summer of 2022 brought flash flooding to London and the surrounding areas, flooding roads and Tube stations.

The rainfall also caused cancellations and delays at Gatwick Airport.

【重温】NGOCN|丁家喜律师:“我爱你们,但我不能放弃理想和信念”

CDT编辑注:人权律师丁家喜是“新公民运动”的主要活动人士之一。在投身人权事业之前,他曾任北京航空工业总公司工程师,并被评为北京市十佳知识产权律师。自2010年起,丁家喜推动“随迁子女就地高考”等教育平权活动;2012年,他与“新公民运动”发起人许志永等人联名向习近平等中央领导人发表公开信,呼吁官员公示财产。2013年4月17日,丁家喜被当局以“非法集会”罪名刑事拘留,罪名随后先后变更为“寻衅滋事”和“聚众扰乱社会秩序”。2016年刑满出狱后,丁于2019年再度因“煽动颠覆国家政权罪”被捕。2023年4月,他被中国当局以“颠覆国家政权罪”判处有期徒刑12年。本文作者苑敏安采访了丁家喜的妻子罗胜春。

丁家喜被宣判12年重刑的前一天,美国时间恰逢复活节,罗胜春买了十二支玫瑰放在美国家中,以此表达过去十年中,每年十二个月她对爱人的思念,也借此期盼他早日归来。

img
2022年7月28日,罗胜春在美国家中抱着丁家喜照片的合影。图片来自自由亚洲

CDT 档案卡
标题:丁家喜律师:“我爱你们,但我不能放弃理想和信念”
作者:苑敏安
来源:NGOCN
发表日期:2023.4.19
主题归类:丁家喜
CDS收藏:人物馆
版权说明:该作品版权归原作者所有。中国数字时代仅对原作进行存档,以对抗中国的网络审查。详细版权说明

12年重刑,这是一场拖延已久的判决,被告人已被关押三年零四个月。罪名是“颠覆国家政权”,获刑者丁家喜,是一名中国律师。与他同一日被宣判重罪的是许志永,中国新公民运动的发起人,组织者,他被判处14年有期徒刑。这一天是2023年4月10日。

这个刑期超出了许多人的预期,引起了巨大轰动。CNN、纽约时报等各大国际媒体纷纷报道,国际社会也表示了强烈的谴责。

作为中国新公民运动的重要组织者之一,丁家喜不是第一次坐牢。早在2011年,他就加入了许志永等人发起的“新公民运动”。追随该运动“自由、公义、爱”的精神,他参与推动教育平权,组织公民聚餐,呼吁官员财产公示等行为。也正因为参加这些活动,2013年4月13日,丁家喜从家中被警方带走,并于次年4月8日被以“聚众扰乱公共场所秩序罪”判刑3年6个月。而同样被捕的许志永,也被以同样罪名判处有期徒刑4年。

出狱后,丁家喜与许志永没有停止行动,仍然奔走中国大地。2019年12月26日,因为在厦门的一场朋友聚会而再度入狱。

与大学就学法律、早早参与社会运动的许志永不同,理工科出身的丁家喜介入公共领域甚晚。2003年,当身为法律学者的许志永因“孙志刚案”发起三博士上书,要求废除收容遣送制度,并进入公共视野时,丁家喜才刚创立他的律师事务所。而在此后许志永创立公盟、探访“黑监狱”、调查城市新移民子女受教育权、推动北京律协民主选举的几年里,丁家喜是一名成功的商业律师,过着众人眼中“上流社会”的生活:打高尔夫、住五星级宾馆、吃鲍参燕翅。

虽然人生经历不同,但最终,因共同的信仰与追求,他们殊途同归。是什么原因促使丁家喜放弃原有的生活,投身社会运动?又是什么让他在饱受牢狱之灾后仍不放弃,成为中国近十年来社会运动的标志人物?回望丁家喜一路走来的历程,会发现,一切皆有来路。

1 “我发现只有律师职业可以改变社会”

1986年,丁家喜考上北京航空航天学院,学习航空发动机设计。当时“文革”结束刚十年,中国社会环境相对开放,各种思潮朝气蓬勃。上了大学后,丁家喜阅读了大量关于“文革”的书籍和文章。这些资料对于初出湖北宜昌一座小县城的他而言,十分新鲜,也让他开始反思“文革”。1989年,他曾和同学们一起到天安门广场游行和静坐。在2017年接受《改变中国》主编曹雅学采访时,他曾表示,“我对当时(学潮)的主张从内心深处是非常认同的,比如反官倒、反腐败、要求民主、打倒老人政治。”

然而,与许多八九一代的政治活动家不同,丁家喜此后并未继续投身社会运动。本科毕业后,他到中国航发沈阳发动机研究所(代号六〇六所)工作了两年,接着又回北航继续读研究生。也是在读研究生时,他结识了妻子罗胜春。

据罗胜春介绍,她们第一次见面是在北航的热学实验室。“当时他穿着沈阳606所的工作服走进来,满面笑容,对我叫了声’师姐’。那一刻我一辈子都忘不了,(他的笑)让房间充满了阳光。”自那以后,两人一见钟情,不久后便开始恋爱。互为初恋的她们,总是形影不离。恋爱后的那个春季学期,丁家喜常骑自行车载着罗胜春穿行校园。罗胜春熬夜写论文时,他也会陪伴左右。

在罗胜春眼里,那时的丁家喜是一个喜欢阅读的文艺青年。 “他喜欢读书,大学时读了很多文学书籍,陀思妥耶夫斯基、托尔斯泰的作品他都读过,目标是读遍诺贝尔文学奖的所有作品。还没完没了地和我讲。好像他什么都能回答。”

那是浪漫的日子。丁家喜和她一起看《日瓦戈医生》的小说,也去看改编的电影。记忆中,他还会聊文革带给人的扭曲,谈及产权私有制的必要性。这对中学时就开始迷恋罗素的自由思想、熟读梁晓声伤痕文学的罗胜春来说,很容易就激起了共鸣。在她记忆中,他和当时的许多大学生一样,有一段时间还迷恋上了写诗,在一个本子上写满了给她的情诗。

“当时他把所有钱都花在了买书上,只有两套工作服。但他还是觉得自己特别富有,有时他也会送我玫瑰花。”一直到今天,罗胜春都记得这些往事。

在罗胜春看来,除了喜欢阅读,丁家喜还是一个关怀他人、阳光乐观的人,他总是笑眯眯的。只有一次,他的妹妹因为婚姻不幸而自杀,这让丁家喜哭了好久,自责没有好好关心妹妹。在罗胜春看来,他是那种把身边人放在首位的人。工作后,他也总借钱给朋友,哪怕常常有借无还。

也许正是丁家喜的这份热心让他选择转行做了律师。研究生时,他就因厌倦专业课程产生了转型的想法,并在业余时间考取律师资格。1995年研究生毕业后,他在北京的中国航天科工三院三〇四所工作了一年多,随后辞职,转行做了律师。据罗胜春回忆,她一开始不理解为何喜欢文学的丁家喜会选择做律师,但他告诉她,“我经过了两年思考,发现只有律师这个职业可以替人说话,为受不公正对待的人说话。这是个可以改变社会的职业。”

对此,丁家喜的朋友吕先生也补充,丁家喜多年后向他透露,自己的兴趣本来是做研究,但他觉得当年要在技术上取得突破没有未来。因为体制内大部分人的心思不在做研究上,而是赚钱、往上爬。

2 商业律师再次转型:投入新公民运动

与许多热心公义的人权律师不同,转行做律师后,丁家喜接触的大多数是商业案子。

2017年,在接受《改变中国》网站主编曹雅学采访时,丁家喜曾说,他在做律师助理时接触过一些刑事案件,但当时因为法庭不采纳辩护方提供的证据,感到伤心与失望,逐渐远离刑辩领域,转而专注他更擅长的技术领域——知识产权。

代理商业案子让丁家喜得以接触社会各界人士。罗胜春回忆,当时丁家喜经常去打高尔夫,去茶馆,和不同人聊天。“大学教授、企业家、政府官员,各种各样的人都有。”用丁家喜自己的话说,广泛社交让他有了“更宽的视野来看待社会”。另一方面,他也在工作中接触到更多不公平的案例。“他当时帮很多企业家应对过政府不合理的规定,帮他们讨回过钱。”罗胜春说。

这些都促使丁家喜思考社会不公背后的共性,以及如何从制度上去解决问题。为了将自己对社会问题的看法直接反映给相关部门,2002年,他加入了中国的民主党派民盟(“中国民主同盟”的简称)。在民盟期间,他曾写过大量提案:在三聚氰胺事件爆发的三个月前,要求加强奶粉质量监管;要求精简二手车的过户手续;要求设立网站公开全国的执行案件。然而,如罗胜春所说,这些提案或石沉大海,或在他提议多年后才正式被纳入政策执行。

屡屡没有回音的提案让他对加入民主党派感到失望,也促使他另寻社会改革的出路。

真正让他决心投身社会运动的是他于2011年2月份的一次赴美访学。据罗胜春描述,当时他在做缅甸、伊朗等国家民主进程的比较研究,几乎每天都在看文献、上网查资料、思考研究问题。陪他一同访学的女儿沙沙曾形容,“每天就看见老爸背着手在房间里走来走去”。另一方面,当时正值国内“茉莉花运动”爆发之际,外面的资讯让他第一次看到原来国内还有这么多抗争的人。这七个月的查阅信息、探索思考,解答了长久以来困扰丁家喜的问题,也仿佛点燃了他对社会运动的热情。

这些研究令他意识到文明(民主)发展的趋势不可逆转。(在那之后)他想要直接推动中国的民主进程,用非暴力不合作的方式。他说只有这样,老百姓才能说话。”罗胜春如此解释那次访学对他的影响。

2011年10月1日回国后,丁家喜开始了他的社会运动之路。经朋友搭线,他在当年的10月10日第一次与许志永见面,并于10月下旬参与了许志永与滕彪等人组织的宪法研讨会。自那以后,他开始加入这个圈子,帮忙组织宪法研讨会和公民聚餐,再到后来,他和许志永、赵常青等人推出要求205位部级以上官员财产公示的活动。从联络各地公民、订场地、到整理通讯录、印制公民文化衫,再到后来要求官员财产公示时,组织倡议书的签名、发放传单、张打横幅,丁家喜几乎事事亲力亲为。多年的律师事务所管理经验,加上他的组织能力,令他很快成了联络组织的核心。

img
许志永与丁家喜的合影。图片来自网络

“新公民运动”的另一位核心参与者李先生回忆,他和丁家喜就是在2012年认识的。当时,丁家喜通过微博私信他,邀请他参加同城聚餐。在那次见面中,丁家喜给他留下的印象非常深刻。“那次聚会我很早就去了,但是老丁比我去得更早。他拿着电脑,记录到会人员的联系方式,还教大家罗伯特议事规则。非常有亲和力,什么都懂,又是律师,自然引起了我的好感和信任。”他说。正是在丁家喜的邀请与介绍下,李先生开始协助联络公民聚会,结识许志永等人,后来一起组织和参与官员财产公示的活动。

除了组织公民聚会,丁家喜也开始关注弱势群体。他为北京拆迁户齐月英提供法律援助,在她“消失”后发表文章为她声援;支持北京南站的上访者,为他们提供经济资助;与律师伙伴一同去青海,为被拘留的异议人士与警方交涉。据罗胜春回忆,丁家喜律师事务所的同事曾在他被捕后告诉她,丁家喜回国后开始将事务所的所有事务交由他人打理,自己只专注维权相关的案子。同事说,“他办公室抽屉里全是访民的诉状。”

面对数量庞大的访民,丁家喜曾向罗胜春表示,“想要让那么多访民每个人都能有声音,不能让访民上访,而是要让当地有人帮他们说话,解决问题。这些最终都归结到:老百姓要权利,要选票。”

尽管丁家喜在家中甚少与她说起他在新公民运动中具体做的事,但她也能明显感受到他的变化。她记得,有一次,丁家喜一边上网,一边大骂:“一定要拆了这个防火墙!”。就连大女儿豆豆也把回国后的爸爸形容作“老愤青”。在2012年六四那天,他还在家中身着黑衫,绝食一天,悼念六四死难者。之后每年六四他都会绝食,甚至包括后来在看守所、监狱。

丁家喜和同伴的活动很快引起了当局的注意。罗胜春至今对丁家喜第一次被国保带走约谈的场景记忆犹新:“当时他被带走谈了十几个小时,我浑身发抖,一直在给他发短信。他短信回复我别担心。”在那次之后,国保开始频繁约谈丁家喜,甚至连家里接送孩子都造成了影响。

当局的举措让罗胜春开始担心丈夫的安危,也担心家庭会受到波及。她表示,当时家人都劝他减少活动。面对家人的劝说,丁家喜一方面坚持,“怎么不去劝坏人别做坏事,而是劝好人别做好事?”另一方面,他也意识到了风险,敦促罗胜春带孩子办签证去美国。

巧合的是,2013年4月13日,就在丁家喜辞去律所主任、陪妻子去申请签证的第二天,他被警方从家中带走。同年4月17日,他被以“非法集会”罪名拘留。2014年4月8日,丁家喜因“聚众扰乱公共场所秩序罪”被判三年半。

那次开庭,他在海淀法庭上陈述时,对自己推动改革的梦想如此总结:“我要做一个有态度、有声音的中国公民。我要做一只蝴蝶。蝴蝶不停扇动翅膀,一定会引发社会变革的飓风。

2016年刑满出狱后,丁家喜对社会运动的热诚不减。

同样因“新公民案”被判了刑的李先生回忆,丁家喜在2016年出狱不久来找过他,说想去美国探访太太及两个女儿。当时正是“709”大抓捕不久,当局对民间力量的打压比新公民运动前更为严厉。因此,李先生不止一次劝丁家喜,去美国后就不要回来。丁家喜却表示不甘心,希望回来继续推动中国的政治改革,落实公民权利、民主自由。在李先生看来,执着的丁家喜难免显得过于理想主义,他也直觉感到他这次探亲后还会回国。

这次赴美探亲并不容易。丁家喜出狱后仍处于当局的严密监视下,不知能否顺利出境。罗胜春回忆:“他以为当局不会放他出来,当时根本没有心理准备,来的时候,他只拿了个特别小的包,装了几件换洗的衣服。”

来到美国后,丁家喜全心全意陪伴家人。在《丁家喜与阿尔弗雷德》一文中,罗胜春曾如此回忆她们十年来仅有的两个月团聚:

“他在阿尔弗雷德这两个月,我大部分时间在上班,很忙。孩子们也都在上学。他每天做饭、洗衣服、看书,跟朋友聊天、听各种各样的新闻频道。他跟我一块去散步,去会朋友,去教堂。他很愿意认识我所认识的所有人。他还跟我一块去跳民间舞,看艺术展,听音乐会,甚至早起和我去练瑜伽。”

“他做饭、做菜、洗衣服做得非常棒。连女儿都说’爸爸来之前,我们家的小屋子从来都没有焕发过如此的光芒’。”2023年4月,在丈夫被宣判12年重刑之后,罗胜春向NGOCN回顾起自己的丈夫,依然不吝惜对他的欣赏。

img
2017年,丁家喜赴美探亲时拍的全家福。图片来自网络

在一家人难得相守的日子,唯一让他们发生分歧的就是丁家喜是否回国这件事。罗胜春在文中写到,一心想要留在中国投身社会运动的丁家喜在行前就让她买了来回票。“他告诉我,只计划在阿尔弗雷德呆两个月。我非常伤心。我说我等了你四年,你只给我两个月的时间,太过分了。”那段时间,一家人每天都在茶余饭后谈起他该留下还是回去,甚至在美国的所有朋友也劝他不要回去。尽管罗胜春反复和他说起各种风险,也揶揄中国不是没了他就不能改变,但丁家喜一直很平静,坚持要回国。

罗胜春记得,丁家喜曾对她说:“我们要有最坏的打算,也要有最好的期待。极权专政就是不合理,我就是要出一份力量。哪怕没有能力建设,见证变革也是一大幸事。”为此,罗胜春感到无奈。甚至一度“恨不得中国政府不让他回国”。但她也是矛盾的。她说:“我本来就没打算说服他留下来,甚至只是想让他待六个月。(就算这样)他都觉得会耽误他回中国做事。”

丁家喜的坚决也在他的行动中有所体现。为了便于回国后继续参与运动,他在国外选择保持低调,没有参加公开活动,仅仅是私下见了几个朋友。哪怕是在他回国前几天,曹雅学邀请他采访时,他最初也不太愿意,担心会引起注意,妨碍他的工作。

罗胜春曾在文中写到,住了一个多月后,丁家喜开始有一种急着回中国的焦躁。她形容,“他对中国老百姓的苦难了解得太多。他觉得本来中国老百姓都可以享受到自由,但他现在却一个人在这里享受,有负罪感,很痛苦。所以他只能在美国享受安逸的生活一段时间,但两个月之后,他可能就会想着访民。那是他骨子里质朴的东西。”

由于不忍看着丁家喜煎熬,罗胜春最终选择了妥协。身为基督徒的她只能安慰自己:也许这就是神赋予他的使命。

在丁家喜回国的那天,罗胜春一人送他去水牛城坐飞机。背着小背包,转身飞吻,灿烂微笑——这就是丈夫留给她的身影。她形容,送走丈夫后,”心里像刀割一样难受,甚至都不知道怎么把车开回来的”。

如今,她还清楚记得,回国的前一晚,丁家喜在沙发上抱着她和小女儿的样子。他说:“我很爱你们。但我只能以常人无法理解的方式爱。我也很想两全。但在常人无法理解的时候,我希望你们能支持一下。我不愿放弃理念和理想。”

没人想到,这次见面成了丁家喜第二次被捕前的最后一次家人团聚。

img
罗胜春与丁家喜的信件往来。图源:罗胜春推特

3 曾经给妻子的“十年之诺”

2018年5月,丁家喜带着给孩子们的礼物和一行李箱的家庭照片,再次赴美参加女儿的毕业典礼,计划留美六个月,好好陪伴家人。但这次,他却遭到了限制出境。

那次对两个人的打击极大。罗胜春形容,“那一个星期我都很难受,基本上觉得以后团聚无望。之前他保证每年都会来看我们,每次都待半年以上。但现在,婚姻、家庭都破灭了。内心只有绝望。”甚至,她一度闪过和丁家喜分手的念头,认为那样彼此就都不会再痛苦了。而丁家喜也因这次出境受限而备受打击。回到家中后,他将原本要带给家人的照片一张一张拍下,传到USB里。这个USB后来被朋友带到美国交给了罗胜春,一直保存在美国的家中。

罗胜春记得,绝望中的她对丁家喜说:“家喜,你总要给我一点活下去的希望吧?”对此,丁家喜恳请妻子给他十年时间。他承诺,从他第一次出狱后算起,如果十年内他没有看到中国发生改变,就会安心将事业交给下一代更有能力的人去做,来美国和家人团聚。

这个十年承诺也为丁家喜的多位朋友所知。老友吕先生回忆,他大概在2019年5月的一场饭局上和丁家喜相识。之后,他曾和丁家喜有过一次彻夜长谈。在那次深聊里,丁家喜笑着说起曾经的牢狱岁月,也说到自己与爱人的“十年之约”。他对此既深感震惊,也敬佩不已。他表示,“对很多从事社会运动的中国人来说,由于受过政治迫害,如果有机会去到一片自由的土地,他们大多都会选择留下。他非常清楚自己面对的风险。他选择回国其实就是选择了为信仰受难。尽管他是轻描淡写,但在我看来这是很悲壮的。”尽管丁家喜并未皈依宗教,但他的献身精神却让吕先生将他视作“基督的门徒”。

背负着这样的承诺,丁家喜四处奔走,组织公民聚会,与大家讨论对社会和政治的看法。另外,他也利用自己此前积累的人脉和资源,调解公民圈内的隔阂矛盾,声援维权人士,资助良心犯及其家属。他梦想着能用十年的时间联结各领域的活动人士,建立公民社会,推动中国的社会变革。

不光是联络以前相熟的伙伴,他也默默帮助着年轻的同道。据吕先生回忆,2019年的一天,丁家喜带了一名刚出狱不久、对前途感到迷茫的政治犯来找他,希望有过相似经历的他能予以帮助和开导。

朋友小河(化名)注意到,再度投身社会运动的丁家喜比之前更加直面问题的根本——专制和极权。她表示,丁家喜的这一变化轨迹也是近十年社会运动演变的缩影。丁家喜参与公民运动的起点正值胡温当政的末年。当时,社会运动的空间还相对宽松,大多数维权运动也因此采用去政治化的策略,例如呼吁官员财产公示、教育平权等新公民运动的主要活动。然而,2012年,习近平当政后,中国更极权化,维权运动也遭到了前所未有的大规模、系统性打压:NGO、维权律师、宗教团体及异议人士几乎被扫荡绞杀。这让很多人更加意识到,无论是女权运动、劳工运动还是环保运动,要想走得长远,最后都殊途同归:反极权。在她看来,这也是他要联结同温层里不同光谱、不同领域的行动者的原因。

能做到这点并不容易。常年从事社会运动的林先生(化名)表示,在他与丁家喜的相处中,他发现丁家喜拥有卓越的行政管理、人际交往和组织能力。加上谦卑、亲和的品质,丁家喜得以将公民圈内不同光谱的人凝聚在一起。“大家一般都很坚持自己的观点,希望得到认可,所以能让大家坐到一起、和平相处,十分难得。”

然而,也许正如林先生所说,能力越突出,越容易被当局视为威胁。回国后,国保一直对丁家喜保持严密监控。据丁家喜的朋友王安娜撰文回忆,丁家喜位于北京的房子楼下长期停有国保的车。为了便于工作,他不得不四处借住朋友家。她回忆,2017年至2018年期间,丁家喜曾几次借住她家。2018年夏天,在丁家喜最后一次借住期间,有一天有几名身着便衣、疑似警察的人非要进门查看。出于对丁家喜的担忧,她让他赶紧换地方。不幸的是,这次见面也成了丁家喜被捕前两人的最后一次见面。

2019年12月7日,丁家喜、许志永及多位来自全国各地的朋友到厦门聚会。聚会上,他们聚餐、唱歌、打台球,讨论公民社会培育和时政事件。一场看似普通的聚会,却在同年12月26日,让参会的丁家喜、戴震亚、李英俊、张忠顺分别从四地被捕。随后,参会的近二十人相继被约谈、传唤、逮捕、刑事拘留。甚至连没有参会的李翘楚也仅因声援男友许志永而遭到了逮捕。这一系列的抓捕被称为“12.26大抓捕”,也是2015年“709大抓捕”以来,中共当局对活动人士最大规模的打压。

这次丁家喜受到了严酷的报复。据丁家喜通过律师透露出来的消息,在长达六个月的指定居所监视居住期间,他曾遭遇酷刑:包括被连续7天的24小时剥夺睡眠、疲劳审讯,以及半个月内每天半个馒头、600毫升饮水,还有长达6个月见不到阳光,有8天被绑在“老虎凳”上。

据已曝光出来的信息,这些酷刑曾让丁家喜脚踝肿得像馒头,还令他身体极度虚弱,两度昏阙。除了酷刑,他被限制与律师会见、仅能通过律师与家人传信。经历了秘密庭审、秘密宣判,他的胡子白了,看起来苍老了很多。身体出现种种问题。被捕至今的近三年四个月里,他的经历让罗胜春时时揪心。

在大洋的彼岸,罗胜春也比丁家喜第一次被捕后更加积极声援。她在社交媒体发声,给丁家喜写信。她向各国政府游说,去联合国发言,接受各方媒体采访,要求跟踪报道,呼吁国际社会予以关注和支持。对中国当局,她写了大量投诉信给各级政府和司法机关,投诉丁家喜被捕后长期被剥夺律师会见与通信权。另一方面,她动员其他12.26案被捕者的家属,共同声援被捕者,在患难中相守。

img
第二次被捕后,罗胜春寄给中国各级政府和司法机关的投诉信。图片来自网络

审判的前一天,美国时间恰逢复活节,罗胜春买了十二支玫瑰放在美国家中,以此表达过去十年中,每年十二月对爱人的思念,也借此期盼他早日归家。

2023年4月10日,丁家喜被控“颠覆国家政权罪”、被判有期徒刑12年。他在不公开宣判的法庭上如此陈述:

面对很多质疑,遇到很多困难,遭受很多挫折,以及个人被酷刑折磨,都不会改变我坚守的理念。所有关心民族前途的中国人,都需要担起我们这一代人的历史责任,这个责任就是根除专制,建设美好中国。这需要我们克服心中的恐惧,大声地发出正义的呐喊,坚决地反对独裁者,坚决地反对特权利益集团,拒绝他们的专制统治。只要我们一起努力,自由之光,民主之光和法治之光一定会照亮神州大地!

后记

判决下达的当天,罗胜春就一直在索要判决书。然而迫于当局的压力,没有人敢提供判决书给她。她对当局连判决书都不敢公开的行为感到无比气愤。宣判后的一个星期里,她接受了各大国际媒体的采访。后续,她计划继续向各国政府呼吁关注中国人权状况,并发布家属声明,要求律师会见和家属探望,追踪丁家喜和许志永入狱后的所有情况。她也加入了一些其它的社会运动,希望与更多的人一起推动中国的社会变革。她形容,与丁家喜此前被捕时相比,自己现在感受到更多的是——“力量、希望、信心”。

img
审判前一天,罗胜春新买的放在家中的12支玫瑰。图片来自罗胜春推特

“这一个星期以来,我是重生了一次。他们选择复活节(宣判),我买这束玫瑰,正是庆祝我自己的复活。朋友打电话过来都以为我崩溃了,但我没有任何的忧伤、恐惧和难受。我有的只是我眼前看到要做的事情和我的力量。我要让所有人都知道丁家喜和许志永的名字。我要让所有人都看看这个国家还有没有救。我有信心,因为神和我在一起。”她说。

我要在我先生被监禁的时候把他没完成的事业完成,而且会比他做得更好。”这是罗胜春的决心与信心。

墙内链接

网页版(第一次打开可能需要一些时间,请尽量复制到非国产浏览器打开)
http://bafybeifyrihvjl2ipk7fb4zjrblv6sris7tvc275lh2ad3o7z5r5ia7tm4.ipfs.pl9oiacm4e1onl3ie.store/article/2023-04-19-Lawyer-Ding-Jiaxi/
图片版(第一次打开可能需要一些时间,请尽量复制到非国产浏览器打开)
http://bafybeifdkwqbi5vtzpvzre5g6lp23d7uj5ncquqtswnxstfia3aurn3xga.ipfs.pl9oiacm4e1onl3ie.store/
PDF版(第一次打开可能需要一些时间,请尽量复制到非国产浏览器打开)
http://bafybeihnrtom5mtawov6w5scw6uytougcx5sds6bxxuetoinnropwz2ymq.ipfs.pl9oiacm4e1onl3ie.store/

Sectarian clashes erupt in Syria despite ceasefire announcement

Getty Images Syrian military and security forces in Suweida. Photo: 15 July 2025Getty Images
Syrian military and security forces in Suweida. Photo: 15 July 2025

The Syrian presidency says it will deploy a new force to halt the deadly sectarian clashes between Bedouin and Druze fighters in the south of the country.

Syrian interim President Ahmed al-Sharaa's office urged "all parties to exercise restraint", amid reports of renewed fighting near the city of Suweida on Friday.

Almost 600 people are reported to have been killed since the violence erupted on Sunday. Government troops deployed to the area were accused by residents of killing Druze civilians and carrying out extrajudicial executions.

Israel later struck targets in Syria to force the troops to withdraw from Suweida province. On Friday, the US ambassador to Turkey said that Israel and Syria had agreed a ceasefire.

In a post on X, ambassador Tom Barrack said that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Sharaa "have agreed to a ceasefire" embraced by Syria's neighbours Turkey and Jordan.

"We call upon Druze, Bedouins, and Sunnis to put down their weapons and together with other minorities build a new and united Syrian identity in peace and prosperity with its neighbours," the envoy said.

Israel and Syria have not publicly commented on the reported ceasefire agreement.

Shortly before Sharaa's office announced its planned military deployment to the south, an Israeli official said Israel had agreed to allow the limited entry of Syrian Internal Security Forces personnel into Suweida for 48 hours to protect Druze civilians "in light of the ongoing instability".

Suweida's predominantly Druze community follows a secretive, unique faith derived from Shia Islam, and distrusts the current jihadist-led government in Damascus.

The BBC correspondent in the Syrian capital says that sectarian hatred of the Druze is now spreading across the country.

The Druze are a minority in Syria, as well as in neighbouring Lebanon and Israel.

Earlier this week, the UN human rights chief, Volker Türk, said his office had received credible reports indicating widespread violations and abuses, including summary executions and arbitrary killings in Suweida.

Among the alleged perpetrators were members of the security forces and individuals affiliated with the interim government, as well as local Druze and Bedouin armed elements, Türk said in a statement.

"This bloodshed and the violence must stop," he warned, adding that "those responsible must be held to account".

The BBC has contacted the Syrian government and security forces about allegations of summary killings and other violations.

In a televised address early on Thursday, Sharaa vowed to hold the perpetrators accountable and promised to make protecting the Druze a "priority".

"We are eager to hold accountable those who transgressed and abused our Druze people because they are under the protection and responsibility of the state," he said.

He went on to blame "outlaw groups", saying their leaders "rejected dialogue for many months".

Sectarian clashes erupt in Syria despite ceasefire announcement

Getty Images Syrian military and security forces in Suweida. Photo: 15 July 2025Getty Images
Syrian military and security forces in Suweida. Photo: 15 July 2025

The Syrian presidency says it will deploy a new force to halt the deadly sectarian clashes between Bedouin and Druze fighters in the south of the country.

Syrian interim President Ahmed al-Sharaa's office urged "all parties to exercise restraint", amid reports of renewed fighting near the city of Suweida on Friday.

Almost 600 people are reported to have been killed since the violence erupted on Sunday. Government troops deployed to the area were accused by residents of killing Druze civilians and carrying out extrajudicial executions.

Israel later struck targets in Syria to force the troops to withdraw from Suweida province. On Friday, the US ambassador to Turkey said that Israel and Syria had agreed a ceasefire.

In a post on X, ambassador Tom Barrack said that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Sharaa "have agreed to a ceasefire" embraced by Syria's neighbours Turkey and Jordan.

"We call upon Druze, Bedouins, and Sunnis to put down their weapons and together with other minorities build a new and united Syrian identity in peace and prosperity with its neighbours," the envoy said.

Israel and Syria have not publicly commented on the reported ceasefire agreement.

Shortly before Sharaa's office announced its planned military deployment to the south, an Israeli official said Israel had agreed to allow the limited entry of Syrian Internal Security Forces personnel into Suweida for 48 hours to protect Druze civilians "in light of the ongoing instability".

Suweida's predominantly Druze community follows a secretive, unique faith derived from Shia Islam, and distrusts the current jihadist-led government in Damascus.

The BBC correspondent in the Syrian capital says that sectarian hatred of the Druze is now spreading across the country.

The Druze are a minority in Syria, as well as in neighbouring Lebanon and Israel.

Earlier this week, the UN human rights chief, Volker Türk, said his office had received credible reports indicating widespread violations and abuses, including summary executions and arbitrary killings in Suweida.

Among the alleged perpetrators were members of the security forces and individuals affiliated with the interim government, as well as local Druze and Bedouin armed elements, Türk said in a statement.

"This bloodshed and the violence must stop," he warned, adding that "those responsible must be held to account".

The BBC has contacted the Syrian government and security forces about allegations of summary killings and other violations.

In a televised address early on Thursday, Sharaa vowed to hold the perpetrators accountable and promised to make protecting the Druze a "priority".

"We are eager to hold accountable those who transgressed and abused our Druze people because they are under the protection and responsibility of the state," he said.

He went on to blame "outlaw groups", saying their leaders "rejected dialogue for many months".

US tech CEO resigns after Coldplay concert embrace goes viral

Awkward moment for couple on screen at Coldplay gig

A US tech company says its chief executive has quit after he was reportedly caught on a big screen at a Coldplay concert embracing a woman, in a clip that went viral.

Astronomer said in a statement: "Andy Byron has tendered his resignation, and the Board of Directors has accepted."

The clip showed a man and a woman hugging on a giant screen at the arena in Foxborough, Massachusetts, before they abruptly ducked and hid from the camera.

The pair were identified in US media as Andy Byron, a married chief executive of Astronomer, and Kristin Cabot, the firm's chief people officer. The BBC has been unable to independently confirm the identities of either person in the video.

The company statement said on Saturday: "As stated previously, Astronomer is committed to the values and culture that have guided us since our founding.

"Our leaders are expected to set the standard in both conduct and accountability, and recently, that standard was not met."

The firm said its board would begin a search for the next leader and their chief product officer would keep serving as interim CEO.

The video of the pair swaying to music at Wednesday night's concert and quickly trying to hide gained millions of views.

After seeing the pair duck, Coldplay lead singer Chris Martin said to the crowd: "Either they're having an affair, or they're just very shy."

Astronomer announced it was launching an investigation into the relationship and placed the CEO on leave shortly after the video went viral.

❌