Before macOS Tahoe, the biggest sticking point in virtualising macOS on Apple silicon Macs has been their lack of support for the App Store. From the outset this has been an ironic limitation. Here’s some of Apple’s most advanced technology running on its latest hardware, and it can’t even run the apps that Apple sells, only those supplied direct by their developers.

VMs can now have iCloud and iCloud Drive support, Messages, FaceTime, FileVault, and plentiful shared folders, but the one thing they have lacked that renders them useless for many users and many purposes is that can’t sign into Apple services, particularly the App Store. Some apps, including those in Apple’s iWork suite, will run in a VM despite it being unable to sign into your account, but you can only window-shop in the App Store, and most of its apps will simply refuse to run, even free ones.

I’ve long suspected that this is an example of Apple Commercial constraining Apple Engineering. To be useful, macOS VMs would have to be exempted limits on the number of Macs authorised to access services, and that could open up the possibility of third-parties bypassing FairPlay and the digital rights controls embedded in macOS. It must be deeply frustrating to those working on virtualisation, knowing that it could be done but won’t be.

So the only substantial new feature for macOS virtualisation in Tahoe is the introduction of ASIF disk images. For the time being, I’m not sure they’re going to change much for most of us who host our VMs on local APFS storage. As they still don’t enjoy proper API support, I don’t see any compelling reason to rush into their use, unless you want to host your VMs in the cloud.

Upgrading to Tahoe has, though, drawn attention to problems lurking for those who created VMs of 50 GB or smaller, who now want to enlarge them for this purpose.

Resizing VMs

Don’t skimp when creating a new VM. Give it a useful size, as its Disk.img is stored as a sparse file, so won’t take all that disk space unless you fill it to capacity. I now make my default VMs 100 GB to ensure there’s ample free for updates and anything else that might arise.

If you do have a treasured VM that’s too small, you may well be able to increase its size, either using Disk Utility or the hdiutil resize command tool if you prefer. To do this, start by duplicating your VM in the Finder. That creates a clone, and lets you fall back to the unaltered original if the resizing goes horribly wrong.

To resize the disk image using Disk Utility, you first have to move it out from inside its VM bundle, easily done in the Finder. Then in Disk Utility’s Images menu use the Resize… command, select that Disk.img and enter its new size. Add a little, around 8%, to allow for overheads, and let Disk Utility get on with the work.

Here’s Disk Utility inside this Tahoe VM, showing its 50 GB virtual disk.

I then resized it to just over 100 GB.

Here it is afterwards, now showing a full 100 GB.

I gather from others that resizing doesn’t always work. If you can’t get it to, then the only way forward is to create a new VM with the larger capacity and copy across the contents of your old VM. One obvious way to make that simpler and more thorough would be to use Migration, either during configuration of the new VM, or shortly afterwards.

I’m very grateful to Michael for telling us of his success in migrating from a small to a larger VM in Tahoe. I’m also more than a little jealous, as I’ve so far been unable to get it to work for me.

I’m also mystified as to how two macOS VMs running concurrently on the same Mac could establish a connection to support the file transfers required in migration. Neither can expose its virtual folders as shared folders for the other, and in any case shared folders are strictly circumscribed. Sharing them over AFP runs into a quirk of their bridged networking, that both of the VMs will default to using the same network IP address. In my failed tests, the destination Migration Assistant was able to recognise the source, but failed to connect to it successfully.

For the moment macOS virtualisation hasn’t made any substantial improvements in Tahoe. It still can’t sign into Apple services, and AI remains unavailable. Let’s hope the next year brings more and better, and realises more of its potential.