Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Before yesterdayMain stream

Lessons from his father

4 July 2025 at 16:54

In this review for the New York Review of Books, I look at two new state-of-the-art biographies of Chinese Communist Party leaders: the former party secretary, Hu Yaobang, whose firing and death led to the 1989 Tiananmen Square democracy movement, and Xi Zhongxun, father of the current leader of China. 

These two books are outstanding for their use of Chinese sources and depth of research. Hu was the most consequential leader but Xi Zhongxun is probably more important due to his son. Through their family life we gain new understanding of how Xi Jinping was raised and clues to how he rules China today. I strongly recommend both. 

The post Lessons from his father appeared first on Ian Johnson.

Interview in 田間 on the China Unofficial Archive

3 June 2025 at 23:01

This is the first in-depth interview I’ve given on the China Unofficial Archives, the online non-profit that I set up in 2023 to promote independent Chinese writing and films. The interview is by Hsiaofan Su of the 田間 Tian Jian newsletter. You can read it here

The interview is in Chinese, but I’ve machine-translated the interview and paste it below for non-Chinese readers:

[Exclusive Interview]
Ian Johnson, Founder of China Unofficial Archives

“This is a unique database of independent thinkers in China, and we hope it will give people a glimpse into the breadth and depth of this anti-history movement.”

HsiaoFan Su
Jun 03, 2025

History needs to be passed on. Only through constant recollection, narration and preservation can people see the present through past experiences. The China Unofficial Archives was established for this purpose. The homepage of the website reads in large letters: “We are committed to collecting, preserving and disseminating the censored and suppressed Chinese folk history.”

The China Unofficial Archives was established at the end of 2023. The opportunity for its establishment came from the book ” Sparks: China’s Underground Historians and their Battle for the Future” (hereafter referred to as “Sparks”) published by its founder Ian Johnson in the same year. This book tells the story of “Chinese folk historians” such as journalist Jiang Xue, documentary director Ai Xiaoming and Hu Jie, who excavate and defend folk historical materials that challenge official narratives.

However, these archives are scattered, and most people, especially Chinese, have difficulty accessing these important historical materials. This gave Zhang Yan the idea of ​​building a website. In order to let more people know about the Chinese Unofficial Archives and use the resources on the website, in early 2025, the Chinese Unofficial Archives website was optimized and began to operate e-newsletters and social media.

Zhang Yan believes that China is part of the global dialogue on “how to face the past”, and Taiwan is included in it, so the significance of China’s private archives to Taiwan is self-evident.

Zhang Yan is a well-known journalist focusing on China. He has lived in China for more than 20 years and has worked for The Baltimore Sun, The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) and The New York Times (NYT) in the United States.

Tian Jian (hereinafter referred to as Tian): Why was the Chinese Unofficial Archives established?

Zhang Yan (hereinafter referred to as Zhang): About five years ago, I gave a speech for the book I was writing, Spark: China’s Underground Historians and Their Battle for the Future. The audience asked me, where can I find these publications and films? Some of them can be found on the Internet, but they are scattered and lack professional organization. They cannot be searched or categorized by labels, so it is not easy to find or summarize them into a systematic database, and most of them can only be found in large research libraries. For most people, especially Chinese, it is difficult to access these materials.

At first, I naively thought that it would be easy to put these articles, books, and movies on the website, but when I actually started to build the website, I realized the complexity of this project! I found that there was so much information that I needed a search function to facilitate users to search by era, theme, content type, and creator. I also noticed that there were many gaps, such as a lack of information on ethnic minorities and more contemporary issues.

So I officially established this database in 2023 and made it a non-profit organization. We then received funding to build a website and hire people to manage and curate it. I participated in the project for free, as a reward for the people I wrote about in my book, who have written about China for decades, and I hope to do something practical to make the voices of the Chinese people heard. We also have a public welfare board of directors. The rest of the staff are all paid.

Tian: What are the main archival materials in China’s private archives?

Zhang: We started by focusing on the major crises of the 20th century, the Anti-Rightist Movement/Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution, and the Tiananmen Square Massacre. We spoke to experts and scholars in these fields and learned about classic books, magazines, and films on these topics. We then expanded our focus to the 21st century, especially the rights protection movement, the social response to the COVID-19 pandemic, and the White Paper Movement.

Our goal is to make works that are out of print or unavailable. We do not upload works that are still available for purchase. For example, we included Yang Jisheng’s classic book on the Great Famine, Tombstone , because the English version of this book is still available on the market, and the Chinese version is out of print, so the website only provides the Chinese PDF version because we do not want to affect Mr. Yang’s right to receive royalties from his work.

For me, as a freelance writer, this has always been something I understand: people should be able to earn income from their work. We publish out-of-print and banned books, mostly from publishers that no longer exist; we also publish some important articles and blog posts, especially those that are banned; and we also have hundreds of underground publications, such as Memory .

The materials in China’s Unofficial Archives cover the Anti-Rightist Movement/Great Leap Forward in the 20th century and the White Paper Movement in the 21st century. (Photo taken from the website of China’s Unofficial Archives)
Tian: Can you briefly introduce the team’s work flow?

Zhang: We have a weekly conference call to discuss the priorities for the next week. We use Google Workspace to work and write, and then put it in a shared folder, which is assigned to specific editors. I review the English content, and I usually confirm it as soon as possible, but sometimes (like now!) there will be a backlog of manuscripts. When everything is ready, we upload the content to the website, and update a new project about every day. A new project refers to a book, an article or a movie, with a bilingual introduction in Chinese and English.

Tian: What new features has the China Private Archives website recently launched?

Zhang: We upgraded the website in February and migrated the platform to Omeka S, an open source database software that is often used by universities to display book collections or art exhibitions. The advantage of Omeka S is that it has a map function, which increases the interactivity of the website. Users can zoom in to see which works we have included in different regions of China. Then click on the link to enter the book or movie page related to the region. It also allows people to see that China’s anti-history is not the work of a few intellectuals in Beijing or a few other big cities. On the contrary, it is a national movement, with memorial spaces, writers, directors, films and books all over the country participating.

We have added a new “Creators” database to highlight these people. On the old website, you clicked on the name of a creator or director, and a bubble window would appear on the screen with a brief introduction of the creator. But now, it will open a new page with a photo of the creator, a more detailed biography, and a list of his works. We think this is a unique database of independent thinkers in China, and we hope that it will give people a glimpse of the breadth and depth of this anti-history movement.

The third new feature is the addition of an e-newsletter . We hope to show readers through the e-newsletter how the books, magazines and films in the database can dialogue with today’s issues, and how these brave writers and directors in the past are still inspiring and valuable to young people today. The e-newsletter can be subscribed for free through Substack, or read directly on our website. Because we are a non-profit organization, we welcome donations of any form, but all content is free to subscribe.

We are currently fixing some bugs and will further add data visualization features. Our goal remains the same: to attract more people to this database.

Share

Tian: Can you further explain how new features such as data visualization will be applied in the future?

Zhang: I think the archive is like a public library, with many valuable collections, but if people don’t know about the library, they won’t come in. The library holds book clubs, workshops, and even more relaxed fashion shows or cocktail parties to attract readers. We don’t hold fashion shows or parties, but we have started sending out e-newsletters to let more people know about what we are doing, and visualizing the materials is another way.

Right now, we have basic map functionality, but in the future, we can do more complex things, such as telling stories with data visualizations. We can start with a person and describe their life, and then as you scroll down, you can see maps, photos, books, and links to other people related to or influenced by this person, leading users to explore other regions and more publications. This feature is currently being used by some large news media organizations such as The New York Times, but as software costs come down, we will have the opportunity to do this. This digital content can also be made into a PDF booklet and provided to users for free download, which will also help promote this content. We expect to launch this new feature in the fall and are preparing to start developing it.

This database is a testament to the extraordinary courage and creativity of many Chinese people who, under the pressure of a powerful state apparatus, have time and again successfully written groundbreaking works about (breakthrough) Chinese history from the 1950s to the 2020s.

Tian: What do you think a “good archive” should do?

Zhang: Projects like ours are inherently endless, but our most important goal is to make it a practical research tool. We want to be as inclusive as possible, so we are also filling in some neglected areas, such as Hong Kong or some recent events.

No library could possibly contain everything, but we hope there will be enough content for people to start their research here.

Tian: You have also started to actively operate social media platforms. Is this to communicate with more people, especially young people who have not experienced the history of the Civil War and the June 4th Movement?

Zhang: That’s our goal—to let people know what we have and encourage them to visit the website often. We update the content every few days and put it in the “Latest Collection” column on the homepage. We also have an e-newsletter and even published a physical book, which is Xiang Chengjian’s autobiography, “Returning from Purgatory: Memories of a Survivor of the “Spark” Case during the Great Famine . ”

Tian: The Chinese People’s Archives was established in the hope of allowing “Chinese people to tell China’s stories”. I’m curious about the role of young Chinese people in this?

Zhang: Except for me (I am not Chinese and not young!), all other staff are Chinese, and several of them are around 30 years old. Although this is just a personal observation and not representative, whenever I give a speech about Spark or related topics, young Chinese people are very interested in this database. We also have many volunteers or interns who have joined, and the feedback we get is very touching.

I think this database is popular for many different reasons. I hope it is mainly because it is useful, of course, but also because it overturns the mainstream view in many countries today: that Xi Jinping and the CCP have completely stifled all independent thinking. Anyone who knows China knows that this is wrong. This database proves this, for example, the creator database shows how many Chinese people have successfully written groundbreaking works about (breaking) Chinese history from the 1950s to the 2020s under the pressure of the powerful state machine, showing extraordinary courage and creativity.

We often think that the great historians and journalists who study China are concentrated in the West, such as Roderick MacFarquhar and Michael Schoenhals on the Cultural Revolution, Frank Dikötter on the Great Famine, and Nicholas Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn on the June 4th Incident in the New York Times. Of course, these people are very great, but too many people don’t know that there are actually many Chinese who have made outstanding contributions in these fields. Our database is to highlight these people’s efforts, which will make many young people proud.

Tian: Do you think the Chinese People’s Archives has any significance for Taiwan?

Zhang: No matter how Taiwanese view China, whether they consider themselves Chinese politically, culturally, or not, China is still Taiwan’s largest neighbor, largest trading partner, and is ruled by a regime that wants to take over Taiwan. If that alone is not enough to understand China’s motivation, then what is?

In Sparks, I also tried to show that the Chinese are part of the global conversation about how to face the past—and Taiwan is part of it. When the book was translated into Chinese and published by Taiwan’s Gūsa Publishing House, they translated the word “underground” in the title as “地下” (underground). I said that this was too straightforward and that “民間” (unofficial or folk) would be more appropriate, because many of the interviewees in the book were not “underground” people who had to hide from the police.

But the editor told me that the word “underground” can resonate with Taiwanese readers, “because during the era of Chiang Kai-shek and Chiang Ching-kuo, Taiwan has a long history of underground publications, such as Chen Yingzhen’s “Human World” magazine.” This made me realize that our destinies as human beings are actually connected, and this alone is worthy of the attention of Taiwanese people.

Tian: What do you think is the most difficult or challenging thing in the operation of the China People’s Archives so far?

Zhang : It’s mainly about time. I’m doing this for free, and it takes a lot of time. We’ve also been thinking about new narrative methods to attract more people to access and use this database. I’d like to quote the Chinese documentary director Hu Jie, who said this in a 2015 interview , which still deeply inspires me:

In that most difficult, violent and terrifying era, there were still people in China who were thinking, and some were not afraid of being beheaded. But they were executed in secret, and we, the descendants, do not know how bravely and generously they died. So there is a moral issue here, because they died for us, and if we do not understand, then this is a tragedy.

Tian: Is there any story that particularly impressed you?

Zhang : This is a funny but thought-provoking story. We have received a lot of feedback from China, and some people are reading these books or magazines for the first time. We are particularly proud of our first physical book: Souls Returned from Purgatory: Memories of the Survivors of the “Spark” Case during the Great Famine, written by Mr. Xiang Chengjian, a survivor of the Jiabiangou labor camp.

“Returning from Purgatory: Memories of Survivors of the “Spark” Case during the Great Famine” is the first physical publication of the China Unofficial Archives. (Photo taken from the China Unofficial Archives)
He couldn’t find a publisher willing to help him publish it, so we proposed to put the book in PDF format on the website for free download. He agreed, but he asked me: What if one day (or sooner or later) your website no longer exists? I told him that we will exist for a long time! But he then asked: “Are you sure you will still exist in 50 years? What about 100 years?” I had to honestly say that I didn’t know. Technology is advancing, and people will die one day, and many things may disappear.

For example, I recently visited the website of the documentary “Morning Sun” , a film about young people during the Cultural Revolution. The official website once included interviews with Song Binbin and many other interviewees , but those videos were played with Adobe Flash Player, and most browsers no longer support the player. So now you can only see the photos and an introduction of these interviewees, and you can’t watch the interview content. Although it can be repaired technically, this example clearly shows that too many stories and materials are disappearing.

So I understood Mr. Xiang’s concerns, and I told him, let’s do this, we will find a regular printing house to print your book, attach an ISBN number, and then send it to major research libraries around the world, so that it can be passed down with our civilization forever, and we will also put it on the website so that more people can search and read it. He agreed, so now it is a physical book, and we sent it to nearly 100 libraries around the world, including Harvard University, Stanford University, the British Library, and the Berlin National Library, etc., and included it in the collection catalog.

This experience is of great significance. It reminds us that when doing online work, we should never assume that everything will last forever. Of course, the birth and disappearance of things is a natural cycle, but we must work hard to find ways to ensure that the efforts of one generation can be passed on to the next generation. This is exactly the original intention of the Chinese Unofficial Archives.

Tian: What other archives do you recommend?

Zhang : Our website has a section called “Other Resources” . I would like to recommend one of the websites in particular: Internet Archive , also known as the “Wayback Machine”, is a non-profit organization that automatically backs up billions of URLs every day.

It has an invaluable tool for people who care about China: a browser extension that lets you manually save web pages. If you’ve ever read a great article on WeChat, only to find it “404” and can’t be found, this extension can solve that problem. When you’re reading the article on your computer, click the extension and it will save a full copy of the page, including all the links.

I’m surprised that many scholars don’t pay attention to this and often cite links to web pages that have not been saved. After a few months or years, half of the links in their references are broken! The Internet Archive can prevent this from happening. For example, all the links I cited in the book “Spark” are archived URLs that will work in the future.

I hope that every reader who reads this will install this extension on their browser and save the web links you think are important. This is a way to save history. Here are the extension links for several major browsers: Chrome , Firefox , Safari .

(see original article for links to those extensions.)

ends

The post Interview in 田間 on the China Unofficial Archive appeared first on Ian Johnson.

Choosing an Apple silicon Mac

By: hoakley
7 May 2025 at 14:30

This coming autumn it’ll be five years since Apple started shipping its first Apple silicon Macs, and it’s already four years since the first M1 iMac. As prices of used Intel Macs are tumbling, more Apple silicon models are coming onto the used market. With a total of 15 basic M-series chips now available, this article tries to help you decide which new or used Apple silicon model to buy.

CPU cores

With such a wide choice, this is perhaps the most complex feature to understand, and it’s likely to make the biggest difference to what your Mac will do. M-series chips have anything from 2-8 Efficiency (E) cores, and 4-24 Performance (P) cores across four different families.

Although folk are usually more concerned with the number of P cores, E cores are responsible for doing much of the routine work, and shouldn’t be ignored. They run most of the background tasks in macOS, from Time Machine backups to indexing all your images and documents for Spotlight. P cores are largely responsible for running the code in your apps, so determine how fast it feels in use.

Most M-series chips have at least 4 E cores, but two, the M1 Pro and M1 Max, have only 2. They compensate for that by running those E cores at higher frequencies when working on heavy background tasks, but subsequent designs have set the comfortable minimum at 4, and the latest base M4 comes with 6. Of the two core types, E cores are the more versatile, as they can run all types of task, background or user, and when running at their maximum frequency can deliver a high proportion of the processing power of a P core. As an E core’s energy use is much lower than that of a P core, they’re a better option when running a laptop Mac on its battery.

The four E cores in this M4 Pro are kept fully occupied in the minutes after starting up, leaving the P cores free for running apps smoothly.

P and E core performance has increased with each new family. This is illustrated in different types of computation, when running one thread on a single core.

M4M3multiTests

The Y axis here gives loop throughput per second for my four basic in-core performance tests, a tight assembly code integer math loop, another tight assembly code loop of floating point math, NEON vector processor assembly code, and a tight loop calling an Accelerate routine run in the NEON unit. Pale blue bars are results for the M1, purple for the M3, and red for the M4, the higher the bar the faster.

Maximum core frequencies have increased from 3.2 GHz in the M1’s P cores to 4.5 GHz in the M4. One crude comparative measurement of overall computing capacity is to total the maximum frequencies for each of the CPU cores in each chip. Those are shown as Σfn in the table below, and the chart that follows it.

These are also complicated by sub-variants and binned versions, where one or two cores have been disabled by Apple, to produce a cheaper chip.

If you’re looking for CPU performance, the M3 Max, and M4 Pro and Max stand out and approach the performance of Ultra chips. But those assume that the software running is able to make full use of all the cores available. There’s no point in paying for the 32 cores in an M3 Ultra if the app you run most can’t use many of them.

Another detail that’s easily overlooked is the instruction set (ISA) supported, notably that of the M4, which includes new features for accelerated matrix and other computation. In this respect, the M2 family has been underrated, as I’ve explained here.

GPU

For most, the choice of CPU cores determines the GPU provided, and for general use they’re well matched. Exceptions to this are when high GPU performance is essential, and to support external displays. In either case you’ll need to check carefully with Apple’s specifications or Mactracker to ensure support. That’s particularly important when driving multiple high-resolution displays.

Memory

Memory options are determined by the chip, with some starting at only 8 GB, which is insufficient even for the lightest use. There was a myth that the use of Unified memory would result in substantial economy in memory use, but in practice that doesn’t work out, and demand for memory has increased with the introduction of new features such as AI.

The danger with this is that using substantial amounts of swap storage is deceptively fast because of the high speed of the internal SSD. As models with 8 GB memory often have small SSDs as well, this is likely to lead to rapid ‘wear’ of the SSD, and some early adopters saw worryingly rapid changes in wear indicators. Fortunately, Apple has recognised this problem, and all M4 models now come with a minimum of 16 GB.

If you’re interested in buying an older model with only 8 GB, at least check its SSD size and wear indicators before parting with your money. Further information about memory requirements is here.

SSD

While it’s possible to enjoy using an Apple silicon Mac with only 256 GB internal SSD, unless you’re frugal in its use you’ll find yourself buying a more substantial external SSD to supplement that. You can start up an Apple silicon Mac from macOS on an external SSD (or even a hard drive, if you must), but that’s more fussy than with an Intel Mac. If you want to consider relying on external storage, this article explains how best to do that.

For most users, a minimum internal SSD requires 512 GB for comfort and a long life.

Buy to upgrade

Until recently, all Apple silicon Macs have been stuck with the CPU cores, GPU, memory and internal SSD that they came with. That may be changing with some now offering SSD upgrades for the M4 Mac mini. However, those are likely to invalidate your warranty, and aren’t likely to be available for other popular models, apart from the Mac Pro.

Recommendations

  • Prefer a later Pro or Max chip over an M1 Pro or Max, to get at least 4 E cores.
  • E cores are more versatile than P cores, and an advantage when a laptop is powered by its battery.
  • If you need to use external displays, check the model’s support for their number and resolution.
  • Look for a minimum of 16 GB of memory.
  • When buying a model with 8 GB of memory, check the wear on its SSD.
  • Prefer a minimum of 512 GB SSD to avoid relying on external storage.
  • Don’t rely on upgrading any Apple silicon Mac’s internal hardware.

Enjoy your new Mac!

Global Voices on the China Unofficial Archives

14 April 2025 at 19:05

In this concise interview, Filip Noubel of the news service Global Voices, interviews me about the evolution of the China Unofficial Archives and our efforts to create a platform for independent Chinese Voices. 

As I mention to Noubel, “Our users are primarily Chinese or overseas Chinese communities”–in other words, we aim primarily at the Sinophone world. At the same time, our descriptions of each item, as well as our databank of writers, directors, and artists, is bilingual because we want non-Chinese speakers to learn a bit about the amazing output of independent Chinese voices over the past 75 years. 

If you want to learn more about this nonprofit, visit the China Unofficial Archives website.

And you can subscribe to the CUA weekly newsletter, which looks at current events in China through the lens of history, via Substack.

The post Global Voices on the China Unofficial Archives appeared first on Ian Johnson.

The PRC’s Original Sin

28 March 2025 at 17:39

In Sparks, I wrote about Fang Fang’s novel Soft Burial but at the time it hadn’t been translated into English. Now, thanks to the effort of UCLA professor Michael Berry, it has just been published by Columbia University Press. 

In this review for The Atlantic magazine, I explain why Fang’s novel is so important. The key to understanding it is that land reform is so sensitive to how the PRC writes its own history. In its telling, it was a great, necessary step that fulfilled a promise of justice to rural Chinese.

In fact, it was an incredibly (and purposefully) brutal campaign to eliminate the local landed gentry, which posed a threat to the CCP’s new authoritarian rule. On top of that, the land that farmers did get was soon taken away from them–and to this day they still cannot own land. 

Fang’s novel exposes this troubled history. Making it more significant is that Fang is not a dissident writer, but a pillar of the establishment. The book was also published by a reputable publishing house and even won a prize–until leftists attacked it. This seemed to make the government aware of how subversive the novel really was and they banned it. 

So kudos to Berry and CUP for bringing out this book in English. It sheds new light on China’s past and makes more of Fang’s works available to the English-reading public. (Besides Soft Burial, they also published The Running Flame, about a woman on death row for killing her husband. And of course readers will know Fang’s Wuhan Diary, which made her internationally famous.)

For more on land reform, please check out the China Unofficial Archives, a registered nonprofit that serves as a home for banned Chinese books, magazines, and films. The archive, where I do volunteer work, has a page on land reform with a few other works on the topic, as well as a page dedicated to Fang Fang (no bio up there yet, but we’re working on it!). 

The post The PRC’s Original Sin appeared first on Ian Johnson.

History and the Cultural Revolution in Holland

25 February 2025 at 04:59

In March I’ll be going to the Netherlands for five days to talk about my favorite topics: Unofficial History, but with an interesting spin: is some version of the Cultural Revolution happening in the West today?

My trip will start on March 12 at 15:15 at Leiden University, where I’ll talk about underground histories with Svetlana Kharchenkova, a cultural sociologist, Bo Wang, a researcher, filmmaker and artist, with the session chaired by  Ying Zhang, a historian at the university. Register here!

After a talk at a class on the 13th, I’ll go to The Hague on the 14th to speak at the Nowhere Bookstore, which is part of a growing diasporic civil society movement outside of China. The bookstore is one of three run by Annie Zhang Jieping, who will moderate. We’ll talk about the link between resistance now and in the past. Registration here.

After  down day on the 15th, I’ll join Annie again on the 16th along with Yuan Li on her Bumingbai podcast for a live recording in Amsterdam. Our topic: why do some Chinese compare events in the United States to China’s Cultural Revolution? That event is unfortunately already sold out but the podcast will air soon after. 

Overall, it will be great to talk to more people from the diaspora and get their feedback on the China Unofficial Archives. We’re looking for more constructive criticism and this will be a great chance. For reasons I don’t entirely get right now, the Netherlands has become a center for Chinese NGO activity–maybe I’ll know more by late March…

The post History and the Cultural Revolution in Holland appeared first on Ian Johnson.

Redefining China

6 February 2025 at 22:32

For decades, Perry Link has been the dean of foreign scholars writing about independent Chinese thinkers, so it’s a real honor to be reviewed by him in The New York Review of Books. In this review of Sparks, he points out that one of my goals is to redefine what we mean by China:

The word “China,” as used by Western journalists and government officials, almost always refers to the thoughts, values, positions, and plans of high-ranking members of the Chinese Communist Party. This is the case when one reads of “China’s” position on Ukraine, “China’s” effort to stimulate domestic consumption, and so on.

In Ian Johnson’s bracing book Sparks, “China” means something else. Johnson writes of Chinese people who uncover momentous truths about their country’s modern history and risk their careers, indeed their lives, to do it. Their values and actions are continuous with ancient moral traditions as well as with the daily life that lies beyond official reach today. They, too, are China.

Over the years, the NYRB has been something like my spiritual home. It was at the urging of its former editor, Bob Silvers, that I began my Q&A series with public intellectuals (still up on the Review’s site here) that gave me the impetus to begin researching Sparks in 2010.  And so it’s especially meaningful to be reviewed in its pages, even if the book came out a year and a half ago! But I think people read the Review for the long-term and its influence isn’t measured in book sales or blurbs that you can extract from a review. Instead, it’s the engagement with the book, which this review does beautifully. 

For people not familiar with the Review, you’ll note that the essay is paywalled but please do sign up and you’ll get a few free articles–and perhaps you’ll also subscribe. In an era of diminishing book review sections in newspapers, supporting family-run publications like the Review is especially important. 

Cover of Feb 27, 2025, New York Review of Books

The post Redefining China appeared first on Ian Johnson.

An epic biography of China’s most famous dissident

25 November 2024 at 04:23

In another era, Perry Link and Wu Dazhi’s biography of Liu Xiaobo would have been reviewed widely and my review–which appeared a year after the book was published–would have been embarrassingly late. But many societies around the world are focused inward, obsessed with populist concerns, and so this tour-de-force biography was essentially not reviewed in the mainstream press at all. A pity, because it gives us the prequel to Xi’s China–a time of bold efforts to build civil society in China and bold people like the Nobel Peace Prize laureate Liu Xiaobo. Read the review here

The post An epic biography of China’s most famous dissident appeared first on Ian Johnson.

Gao Ertai: The desert flower that keeps blooming

19 August 2024 at 00:17

“Some see in his critique of the Mao era parallels to today: the arbitrary rule of an aging leader, harsh treatment of dissent, and government programs that encourage people to inform on one another.” My profile of the octogenarian essayist Gao Ertai, who lived for years in the deserts of western China and now resides in Las Vegas.

Read the article  in The New Yorker online here.

Read the Chinese translation in the Boston Review of Books (波斯頓書評) here.

The post Gao Ertai: The desert flower that keeps blooming appeared first on Ian Johnson.

肌肉記憶 詳細解析(中):改變基因?

5 December 2021 at 14:35
上集說到,肌核假說只是肌肉記憶的一部份,但其他機制竟然可以改變基因?

前言

我們可以為了方便解釋而把肌肉記憶簡單區分為「肌肉」和「神經」兩個系統。因肌肉系統的記憶機制相對複雜,所以除了上集介紹的「肌核假說」外,本文還要來講解肌肉系統的另一個記憶機制:表徵遺傳學。

簡介

雖然我們現在知道「肌核假說」恐怕不是肌肉記憶的主要解釋,但別忘了,肌核本身對肌肉的成長還是至關重要,因為細胞核掌握了一個細胞的遺傳資訊,也會直接影響蛋白質的製造。

一個人幾乎所有的細胞(但不是全部)都擁有同一套基因,也就是父母留下的遺傳資訊。這些遺傳資訊以 DNA 的形式被保存在細胞核內,而細胞則會依照此基因藍圖來產生結構與功能。但既然資訊都是同一套,那為什麼神經、肌肉、脂肪等各式各樣的細胞,都會有不同的樣貌與功能呢?

這是因為,不同細胞對這一套基因組會有不同的表現。可以把它想成所有國家的廚師都擁有同一本超級世界食譜,但不同國家的廚師常做的料理會不一樣。例如台灣的廚師最常使用東方菜的食譜、有時會烹飪歐美料理、但幾乎是完全不會翻閱拉丁美洲傳統民族料理的食譜。因此,雖然每個廚師都擁有同一本超級食譜,但不同廚師製作出的料理類型則不盡相同。

雖然人體不會主動改變 DNA 序列(突變才會),但我們可以改變細胞讀取 DNA 的方法。這種「在不改變 DNA 序列的情況下,改變基因表現」的學科,即為「表徵遺傳學 epigenetics」,也是肌肉記憶的熱門候選機制。今天就要來帶大家了解,有什麼跟肌肉記憶有關的表徵遺傳學機制。

重點

  1. 訓練後,能促進增肌的基因會更容易被表現、而能抑制增肌的基因會被關靜音,也就是讓整體遺傳資訊更能幫助肌肥大。
  2. 就算停練而導致肌肉縮水,這些基因表現的改變仍會被留下來,使再度訓練時的增肌效果更佳。
  3. 基因的「甲基化」可以控制這段 DNA 被讀取的次數,若促進增肌的基因甲基化減少,則可以被讀取更多次,幫助增肌。
  4. miRNA(微 RNA)會防止對應的蛋白質被合成出來,若身體減少特定的 miRNA 生產,則可以增加特定的蛋白質合成,幫助增肌。

表徵遺傳學與健身的關係

不管是肌肉結構、訊息分子、還是生化反應的催化劑,許多都是由蛋白質構成的,而 DNA 就是蛋白質的建構藍圖。當我們讀取 DNA 的一段基因,經過轉錄與轉譯後,即能製造出特定蛋白質。也就是說,若我們能控制 DNA 的讀取,即能改變肌肉合成的反應。而能做到這件事的,就屬「表徵遺傳」的改變了。

當我們訓練後,促進增肌的基因會被頻繁表現出來、而抑制增肌的基因會被關靜音,使細胞能製造更多與增肌有關的蛋白質。此外,就算停練一段時間,這些基因表現的改變仍會被留存,代表再度回歸訓練時,我們的細胞能快速進入增肌準備,讓肌肥大更有效率。

以下,要來介紹細胞會做出哪些改變來操控表徵遺傳,並解釋目前學界有的研究證據。

先備知識:怎麼從 DNA 變成蛋白質?(已了解的可跳過)

想像一下:世界上所有的料理都被集結成一大本超級食譜,放在一個房間內。若想做一道菜,我們必須去翻閱超級食譜,但沒必要把成千上萬的其他美食作法也帶走,所以我們只要抄錄所需料理的部分。把抄錄本帶出房間後,就可以在廚房把這道菜烹飪出來。

回到 DNA 這邊:身上所有的基因都存在 DNA 之中,放在細胞核內。若想製造一種蛋白質,我們必須去讀取 DNA,但沒必要把所有基因的資訊也帶走,所以我們只需抄錄(a.k.a.「轉錄」)所需片段,把抄錄本(a.k.a.「RNA」)帶出細胞核後,就可以在細胞質裡面合成出蛋白質(a.k.a.「轉譯」)。

(圖一)從 DNA 到蛋白質

別忘了,這本超級食譜雖然每個細胞都有,但不同細胞會讀取的段落不同,所以才能產生不同的蛋白質來實現各式各樣的結構與功能。

基因的隱形斗篷:甲基化

當肌肉細胞受到重訓刺激時,肌核(肌肉細胞核)中的 DNA 會被改變讀取方法,使促進增肌的基因被更頻繁轉錄、而抑制增肌的基因則減少轉錄頻率。那細胞是如何改變 DNA 的讀取方法呢?答案是「甲基化」。

可以把「甲基」想成隱形斗篷,當我們把甲基安裝在一段基因上時,這段基因就會被靜音、忽略。若把甲基拿走,就會讓這段基因又開始顯現出來、並能被轉錄成 RNA。

不過,甲基化並不是非開即關,而是能控制不同的顯現程度,所以一段基因可能只是被減少轉錄頻率,而非被完全靜音。當一段基因被安裝上更多甲基而變得更隱形時,我們稱之為「高度甲基化」;相反地,若基因被移除甲基而增加表現頻率,則被稱為「低度甲基化」。

研究(如 12)發現:重訓之後,許多基因會低度甲基化,例如與 mTOR 相關、能提升肌肉蛋白合成的基因;一小部分的基因則會高度甲基化,如與細胞凋亡相關的基因。

這一系列的表徵遺傳改變使肌肉細胞的增肌效率大增。更重要的是,就算停練之後,這些改變仍能被保留下來(能保留多久仍有待確認),使再度訓練時擁有比初始階段更有效率的肌肥大。這就是「甲基化的肌肉記憶」。

半路殺出個程咬金:miRNA

DNA 會被轉錄成 RNA,然後 RNA 會被轉譯成蛋白質……其實沒那麼簡單。不是所有 DNA 片段最後都會成為蛋白質,只有轉錄成「信使 RNA(mRNA)」的才會。在其他 DNA 片段中,有一種會被轉錄成「微 RNA(miRNA)」,也就是表徵遺傳的另一個控制因素。

miRNA 就像半路殺出的程咬金,會在 mRNA 轉譯成蛋白質前阻止它,讓這個基因無法製造出蛋白質。也就是說,就算基因沒有被「甲基隱形斗篷」蓋布袋,它最後還是無法產出蛋白質。所以我們會希望減少跟增肌相關的 miRNA。

2020 的一篇研究發現,老鼠經過阻力訓練後,miRNA-1 的量會顯著減少。miRNA-1 是常見於骨骼肌中的一種 miRNA,它會抑制肌肉細胞的生長,因此若數量減少則能幫助增肌。

更重要的是,當老鼠經歷長達 6 個月的停練後,雖然肌肉大小和肌核數量都已打回原形,但 miRNA-1 的量仍然繼續低迷,代表肌肉的基因表現上是適合增肌的、也代表肌肉細胞能透過 miRNA-1 來保有先前訓練的「記憶」。

但還是無法完全歸因於它

雖然表徵遺傳學這個解釋相當合理且誘人,讓人不禁推論肌肉記憶就是它的功勞,但其實我們離那步還有些距離。

首先,我們並不知道在人身上,到底多久的重訓經歷可以使表徵遺傳產生變化、也不知道這個變化到底能維持多久。再者,我們並不知道不同訓練年資與程度,會如何影響表徵遺傳的差異。最後,我們也不知道表徵遺傳的差異究竟會多劇烈地影響增肌。

即使如此,在學界中表徵遺傳學仍然是肌肉記憶的一大巨星,也相信未來更多的相關研究可以帶我們更加認識這個機制。

總結

肌肉細胞可透過表徵遺傳的改變,去影響基因的表現方式,進而影響增肌的效果,而其中較明顯的機制是透過「甲基化」和「miRNA」去做改變的。停練後,促進增肌的表徵遺傳並不會馬上消失,而是能繼續維持,幫助我們回歸訓練時能快速回到原本的程度,這就是肌肉記憶的表徵遺傳學假說。

至此,我們介紹了兩種肌肉記憶的肌肉系統機制:曾經風光的「肌核假說」和具有無限潛力但仍充滿未知數的「表徵遺傳學假說」。但重訓表現的快速恢復,除了肌肉本身的成長外,也有神經系統的貢獻。本系列的最後一篇文章,會再帶大家了解肌肉記憶的神經系統機制。

China Unofficial Archives launch

14 December 2023 at 04:42

After months of work, on Dec. 13 we launched the China Unofficial Archives, a repository of hundreds of underground periodicals, books, and movies. 

The site is a project that I began to think about when I was working on Sparks, my book on counter-history in China. One key point is that the digital revolution has made it easier than ever for people inside an authoritarian state like China’s to share information by basic technologies, such as PDFs or digital films. And yet much of the information sharing is ad hoc. A person may get an email with a PDF book attached on, say, the Cultural Revolution, but not realize what else has been published or filmed on this topic. Or they might like the author but might not have an easy way to access that person’s works. An online archive, I thought, could help fill this gap.

After incorporating the archive as a non-profit over the summer, I secured funding from a charity, hired a web designer and had invaluable help from people such as the independent journalist Jiang Xue (who also features in Sparks). 

We “launched” via an online event sponsored by Westminister University’s China Centre. I was joined by Gerda Wielander, who has done much research on history and state narratives in China, and Shao Jiang, a London-based scholar who advises the archive. The event will eventually be posted to YouTube. 

For a description of what the site aspires to be, you can see its “About” page here. I also wrote the first in what I hope will be a series of “Curators Notes” by me and various people involved in curating the site. 

As I mention in the note, this is a work in progress. We’ve already received very useful feedback on how to improve it and are also in the middle of uploading hundreds of new movies and other files. We currently have about 850 items in the archive but need to double it–and fill in many holes (also outlined in my note)–before it will really take shape. 

Stay tuned…

The post China Unofficial Archives launch appeared first on Ian Johnson.

Best books of 2023

20 December 2023 at 02:49

With 2023  almost over, five important publications have included Sparks on their “best of 2023” lists, including The New Yorker, The Economist, The Financial Times, The New Statesman, and The Tablet

 

The New Yorker

“With firm but never dogmatic moral conviction, Johnson pays tribute to the writers, the scholars, the poets, and the filmmakers who found the courage to challenge Communist Party propaganda. These dissenters looked beyond the official lies about the past and the present, and decided to document the truth about forbidden topics, including Mao Zedong’s campaigns to massacre putative class enemies. They often paid for their candor with long prison terms, torture, or death. Their conclusions—presented in homemade videos, mimeographed sheets, and underground journals—didn’t reach a wide audience when they appeared. And yet, as Johnson makes clear in his superb, stylishly written book, the value of their legacy is incalculable.”

 

The Economist

“A Pulitzer-prize-winning journalist describes the valiant e!orts of China’s “underground historians”, a motley and persistent group of academics, artists, film-makers and journalists attempting to correct the sanitised official record and provide truthful accounts of history. A rare insight into the extraordinary risks that some Chinese take to illuminate the darkest corners of communism.”

 

 

The FT

“‘Who controls the past, controls the future,’ wrote George Orwell. This is a fascinating and important story of dissident historians in China, who are challenging the Communist party’s authorised version of history.”

 

 

 

 

The New Statesman

“In a year of unrelentingly bleak news, I’ve chosen Sparks  (Allen Lane), Ian Johnson’s evocative study of China’s underground historians documents both the relentless crackdown on civil society and intellectual freedom under Xi Jinping, and the quiet courage of those who refuse to be crushed. Drawing their inspiration from earlier acts of resistance that appeared hopeless in their own times, these independent scholars, filmmakers, and journalists have come to view their work as time capsules, determined to preserve an accurate record of the country’s past for future generations. ‘They want future Chinese to know,’ Johnson writes, ‘that in the 2020s, when things had never been darker…. Not everyone had given in.'”

 

The Tablet

“Controlling the interpretation of what has happened in China since the Communist revolution is an integral part of President Xi Jinping’s ever-tightening grip on his vast country. In Sparks: China’s Underground Historians and Their Battle for the Future (Allen Lane, £25; Tablet price £22.50), Ian Johnson charts the brave attempts of individuals, the ‘underground’ historians, to challenge the party line and reveal the brutal arbitrariness which has marked its rule from the beginning.”

The post Best books of 2023 appeared first on Ian Johnson.

SPARKS Tour Dates

11 August 2023 at 09:17

We’re building out a tour this September, October, and November to talk about my new book  Sparks: China’s Underground Historians and Their Battle for the Future.

I’ll start out on the launch date, Sept. 26, at McNally Jackson in New York City, followed the next day with a talk at the Harvard Bookstore in Cambridge, MA. Then back to NY for a Council on Foreign Relations talk, down to Washington DC for talks at Georgetown and Politics & Prose, followed by a trip to the U.K., and then the West Coast of the United States.

Next year: the Association for Asian Studies meeting in Seattle (where I’ve organized a panel on counter-history in China), Stanford, SMU in Dallas, and more… For some of the details, please visit my Sparks-tour page here

 

The post SPARKS Tour Dates appeared first on Ian Johnson.

Coming sept 2023: Sparks

13 April 2023 at 03:35

Coming 26 September 2023: Sparks: China’s Underground Historians and their Battle for the Future–my first book in six years, a chronicle of Chinese people inside China today who are challenging the Communist Party on its most sensitive topic, its control of history. 

Summary

From the back cover:

A documentary filmmaker who spent years uncovering a Mao-era death camp; an independent journalist who gave voice to the millions who suffered through draconian Covid lockdowns; a samizdat magazine publisher who dodges the secret police: these are some of the people who make up Sparks: China’s Underground Historians and their Battle for the Future, a vital account of how some of China’s most important writers, filmmakers, and artists have overcome crackdowns and censorship to challenge the Chinese Communist Party on its most sacred ground–its monopoly on history. 

Why history? The past is a battleground in many countries, but in China it is crucial to political power. In traditional China, dynasties rewrote history to justify their rule by proving that their predecessors were unworthy. Marxism gave this a modern gloss, describing history as an unstoppable force heading toward Communism’s triumph. The Communist Party builds on these ideas to whitewash its misdeeds and justify its continued hold on power. Indeed, one of Xi Jinping’s signature policies is the control of history, which he equates with the party’s very survival.

But in recent years, critical thinkers from across China have begun to challenge this state-led disremembering. Using digital technologies to bypass China’s ubiquitous surveillance state, their samizdat journals, underground films, and guerilla media posts document a persistent pattern of disasters: from famines and purges of years past to ethnic clashes and virus outbreaks of the present.

Based on ten years of on-the-ground investigations and interviews, Sparks challenges stereotypes of a China where the state has quashed all free thought, revealing instead a land engaged in of one of humanity’s great struggles of memory against forgetting–a battle that will shape the China that emerges in the mid-21st century.

 

Advance Praise

    For more than three decades, Ian Johnson has conducted some of the most important grassroots research of any foreign journalist in China. With Sparks, he turns his attention to history—not the sanctioned, censored, and selective history promoted by the Communist Party, but the independent histories that are being written and filmed by brave individuals across the country. This book is a powerful reminder of how China’s future depends on who controls the past.

            —Peter Hessler, MacArthur grantee, National Book Award Winning author of Rivertown, Oracle Bones, and Strange Stones.      

 

   An indelible feat of reporting and an urgent read, Ian Johnson’s Sparks is alive with the voices of the countless Chinese who fiercely, improbably, refuse to let their histories be forgotten. It’s a privilege to read books like these. 

          —Te-Ping Chen, author of Land of Big Numbers, and Wall Street Journal national correspondent.

 

     China’s most famous modern writer Lu Xun predicted that “as long as there shall be stones, the seeds of fire will not die.” In Sparks Ian Johnson introduces us to a new generation of unofficial historians — modern-day “seeds of fire.” Their work will survive the Xi Jinping era, both to shed light on the past and to illuminate China’s better future.

          — Geremie R. Barmé, editor, China Heritage.

 

     Ian Johnson’s Sparks was a revelation: this historian from overseas spent years penetrating the world of underground Chinese historians, becoming in his own right a recorder of pioneers such as Hu Jie, Ai Xiaoming, and Jiang Xue, who use text and video to record China’s lost history.

            —Liao Yiwu, author of The Corpse Walker, God is Red, For a Song and a Hundred Songs, and recipient of the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade.

 

     Sparks tells the stories of underground historians who are determined to write down China’s hidden histories of famines, political campaigns, massacres, and virus outbreaks. These stories show why Xi Jinping wants to control history–because memories like these are sparks of light in a heavy darkness.

            —Li Yuan, New York Times columnist and host of the Bumingbai podcast.

 

     In the long years of Chinese people’s pursuit of justice and equality, preserving historical truth has always been a fierce but invisible battle. As Ian Johnson’s Sparks shows, today’s fighters for the truth are backed by vast armies—the seen and unseen, the living and the dead—who together are prying open the lies on which totalitarianism is built.

          —Cui Weiping, Beijing Film Academy professor, translator of Vaclav Havel into Chinese.

 

        Ian Johnson has presented a powerful narrative of how the human spirit has survived the cruel repression of Maoist totalitarianism and is still doing the same against Xi Jinping’s determined efforts to impose a new form of digital totalitarianism. In telling the individual stories of Chinese citizens who choose to defend freedom and dignity, Johnson has also provided a powerful illustration of how Xi’s repressive regime works.  A must read for anyone interested in the Chinese and China.

            —Steve Tsang, historian of Hong Kong, director of the China Institute at the School of Oriental and African Studies, London.

 

   This is a necessary book charged with historical urgency. The sparks, left by the eponymous underground magazine suppressed in the 1950s, are preserved here and ready to burst into a  firestorm.”

            —Ha Jin, author of the National Book Award-winning novel Waiting

 

     This compelling and highly enjoyable book will greatly enhance the general reader’s understanding of the subtle counter-currents of resistance at work in Chinese society below the smooth surface of control and compliance. In fifteen chapters and a conclusion, the author provides a comprehensive and detailed picture of what he calls “underground history” and its practitioners in mainland China—amateur or one might say guerilla historians who devote considerable efforts to reconstructing the past through independent inquiry, bypassing and challenging state-condoned narratives of the past.

        —Sebastian Veg, author of Minjian: The Rise of China’s Grassroots Intellectuals, professor of history at the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences, Paris. 

Publication Rights and Editions

This book will come out in the United States and Canada via Oxford University Press, and via Penguin (Allen Lane) for other English-language rights areas, including the U.K., Australia, New Zealand and Asia. 

Foreign rights have also been sold for Korea, Japan, and Taiwan.

Some notes on the covers

The US and Canada cover (at the top of this post) was made by Yang Kim, a Brooklyn-based book designer who works for Crown (Random House). She used a collage of images inside a torch, which she took from an image used in a 1960 student journal, Spark, which was the inspiration for my book title. Thanks Yang for such a brilliant job!

The designers for Allen Lane in London opted to use an Ai Weiwei papercut called “River Crabs.” Ai uses the traditional art form of paper cutting and combines it with topical issues, such as pollution, protests, and the state’s demolition of private property. River Crabs are a form of Internet slang for censorship and protests against it.

Sparks

Photos

The book contains more than thirty photos. Some of them are historical, such as images of the students who founded the original journal. Many of these people ended up in labor camps for years and some were executed. Thanks to several Chinese historians, such as Song Yongyi and the documentary filmmaker Hu Jie for sending me these valuable historical prints. These images survived the maelstrom and thanks to digital technologies are now part of China’s collective memory–a key theme of this book.

Four students from Lanzhou University exiled to the city of Tianshui, standing in front of the party offices. They would publish the journal Spark, which has become a touchstone in the battle for China's history.
The first page of the 1960 journal Spark, founded by Lanzhou University students exiled to western China during the Anti-Rightist Campaign. They witnessed the Great Famine and wrote trenchant essays on China's political system that still echo today.

Others photos in the book were taken by the Singaporean artist and former Magnum photographer Sim Chi Yin, who accompanied me on some of the interviews. Chi Yin did beautiful landscapes that caught the theme of repressed and recovered memories that lie at the heart of this book. 

Widow's Bridge, Daoxian, where many were beaten and tossed into the river in August 1967.

Chi Yin also took portraits of key people involved in the piece, especially the journalist Jiang Xue and the documentary filmmaker Ai Xiaoming. 

Chinese writer Jiang Xue, whose essays were among the most popular accounts of China's draconian zero-Covid policy.
Chinese underground filmmaker and feminist scholar Ai Xiaoming in her home in Wuhan.

The book also contains reproductions of artworks that try to counter the “tyranny of the archive”–that reality is more than state-controlled archives can ever show us. 

The artist and filmmaker Hu Jie's depiction of the poet Lin Zhao, forced to wear a "monkey mask" to prevent her from speaking in the days before her execution. Hu's work is an effort to fill in the archives' voids, allowing us to feel the past more viscerally than is possible with words.

Maps

Once again I was fortunate enough to work with the mapmaker Angela Hessler, who put together the beautiful map that you can see below, which reflects a key theme in the book–the landscape of memory. The logo of the magazine Spark is reproduced in the lower left-hand corner, while the logo of the contemporary journal Remembrance is in the lower right. The little torches indicate key locations mentioned in the book. Thanks Angela!

Purchase

Last but not least….the book is available now for preorder from OUP, Penguin, Amazon, Barnes, and any indy bookstore that you frequent.

I’d appreciate any pre-orders as it helps improve how the book is marketed, both in the bookstore and online. And afterwards, any reviews or feedback to the bookseller would be great–it helps keep the book in stock and in print. 

The post Coming sept 2023: Sparks appeared first on Ian Johnson.

❌
❌